About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

Living
Floorplan
Entry Way
Other
Dining
Kitchen
Bedroom
Bath
Exterior
View/Area

131 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130

$387,900

Last sold 11/12/2025 after 120 Days

4
bed
2
bath
4,284
Sqft ($91/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 131 E Chestnut St

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1900

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 3,485 Sqft

Movoto estimate

Property description

Find your sanctuary in this one-of-a-kind home! Originally build in 1851 as Emmanuel Lutheran Church, later known as the B'Nai Israel synagogue, and is currently a converted private residence. This versatile open-concept design offers 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a large kitchen with a walk-in pantry, a generous recreation room complete with pool table. This historical property blends preserved architectural elements with modern living features including gothic stained-glass windows throughout, arched church doors, soaring vaulted ceilings, original hardwoods, and a bell tower. Perfect for artists, musicians, or continue as Airbnb revenue. Minutes from downtown's vibrant art galleries and museums, coffee shops and restaurants. If you're looking for a property with profound history, architectural beauty, and endless creative potential, make your appointment today!

Listed by

Listing Agent - Jenifer M Campbell

Listing Agent Contact: 740-689-9090

Listing Office - Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc

Source: Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS

MLS#225026079 • last updated 9 months ago

Movoto checked Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS for data 7 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	Central Air, Window Unit(s)
Heating	Forced Air
Virtual Tour	N/A
MLS #	225026079
Status	Closed
SubType	Single Family Residence
Living Area	4284
Lot Size (SqFt)	3484.8
Lot Size (Acres)	0.08
Property Tax	2375
Year Built	1900

Interior
# of Full Baths	2
Total # of Bathrooms	2
Total # of Bedrooms	4
Flooring	Wood, Carpet

Exterior
Foundation	Stone
Parking	On Street

Amenities / Utilities
Water Source	Public

Location
High School District	LANCASTER CSD 2305 FAI CO.
APN	05-35049-300

Lot/ Land Details
Possible Use	Commercial

$392K

Range: $325K-$458K

Last 30 days

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Nov 2025
Public Records
Nov 24, 2025 Sold
$387,900
Nov 2025
MLS # 225026079
Nov 13, 2025 Sold
$387,900 (-3.0%)
Oct 15, 2025 Active
—
Aug 28, 2025 Price Change
$399,900 (-5.9%)
Aug 8, 2025 Price Change
$424,900 (-3.0%)
Jul 29, 2025 Price Change
$438,000 (-2.7%)
Jul 15, 2025 Listed
$450,000 (+33.1%)
Aug 2021
Public Records
Aug 2, 2021 Sold
$338,000
Jun 2021
MLS # 221009167
Jun 11, 2021 Sold
$338,000
Apr 12, 2021 Contingent Finance And Inspection
—
Mar 29, 2021 Listed
$338,000

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2023
$5,692 +148.1%

$62,830
2022
$2,294 +169.1%

$62,830 +91.79%
2021
$853

$32,760
2019
$853 -46.2%

$32,760 -21.48%
2018
$1,585 -0.1%

$41,720 -18.47%
2017
$1,586 +2.7%

$51,170
2016
$1,545 +1.1%

$51,170
2015
$1,528 +5.0%

—
2013
$1,456

—

131 E Chestnut St
$387K
Downtown Lancaster
$449K +25% y/y
43130
$299K +3% y/y
Lancaster
$299K +3% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
129 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$199,000	3/1	1,578	0.02
135 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$243,000	3/1	2,208	0.02
139 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$199,000	2/1	876	0.02
143 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$313,000	3/1	2,272	0.03
149 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$411,000	4/2	3,200	0.04
151 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$220,000	4/1	1,792	0.05
138 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$315,000	2/2	2,180	0.05
142 E Chestnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130	$342,000	4/2	2,728	0.05

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.