Open Houses in Fishers Island, NY
No Homes in this area
There’s no inventory based on your search criteria.
Adjust filters to expand your search.
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
Explore nearby locations
The prices shown are the median list prices.Groton Homes for sale
$302,500
New London Homes for sale
$295,000
Norwich Homes for sale
$257,000
Waterford Homes for sale
$339,900
Westerly Homes for sale
$479,000
Mystic Homes for sale
$1,049,500
Stonington Homes for sale
$749,950
Niantic Homes for sale
$659,425
Old Saybrook Homes for sale
$812,450
East Lyme Homes for sale
$477,400
Old Lyme Homes for sale
$532,500
Westbrook Homes for sale
$517,450
Ledyard Homes for sale
$454,900
Old Mystic Homes for sale
$399,000
East Hampton Homes for sale
$8,575,000
Charlestown Homes for sale
$999,999
11937, NY Homes for sale
$2,300,000
11944, NY Homes for sale
$1,275,000
11963, NY Homes for sale
$2,500,000
11971, NY Homes for sale
$1,295,000
11930, NY Homes for sale
$4,197,500
11954, NY Homes for sale
$2,325,000
11964, NY Homes for sale
$1,575,000
11957, NY Homes for sale
$1,650,000
11939, NY Homes for sale
$1,200,000
11975, NY Homes for sale
$6,650,000
New London County Homes for sale
$375,000
Washington County Homes for sale
$639,900
Narrow your search
Schools
Frequently Asked Questions about Fishers Island, NY
In September 2026 Fishers Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $6.5M, which is a 4% decrease to August 2025 last month, and a 4% decrease to September 2025 last year. The median value of a home listed to buy in Fishers Island in September 2026 was $1,230 per sqft, which is a 4% decrease to August 2025 last month, and a 4% decrease to September 2025 last year.
It is expensive to live in Fishers Island. Buying a home in Fishers Island is 15% more expensive compared with the national average.
Yes now is a good time to buy property in Fishers Island, in September 2026, homes in Fishers Island have decreased in value (price per sqft) by 4% in the last year compared with September 2025.
In September 2026, homes to buy in Fishers Island spent an median 455 days on the market, a same September 2025 last year.
In September 2026, Fishers Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $6.5M, with 25% down you would need $38.7K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $1.32M.
Yes now is a good time to sell your house in Fishers Island, in September 2026, homes in Fishers Island have decreased in value (price per sqft) by 4% in the last year compared with September 2025.