How much does it cost to buy a house in Fishers Island, NY?

In May 2026 Fishers Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $6.5M, which is a 4% decrease to April 2025 last month, and a 4% decrease to May 2025 last year. The median value of a home listed to buy in Fishers Island in May 2026 was $1,230 per sqft, which is a 4% decrease to April 2025 last month, and a 4% decrease to May 2025 last year.

Is it affordable or expensive to live in Fishers Island, NY?

It is expensive to live in Fishers Island. Buying a home in Fishers Island is 15% more expensive compared with the national average.

Is it a good time to buy property in Fishers Island, NY?

Yes now is a good time to buy property in Fishers Island, in May 2026, homes in Fishers Island have decreased in value (price per sqft) by 4% in the last year compared with May 2025.

Is the Fishers Island, NY housing market slowing down?

In May 2026, homes to buy in Fishers Island spent an median 455 days on the market, a same May 2025 last year.

How much money should I make to buy a house in Fishers Island, NY?

In May 2026, Fishers Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $6.5M, with 25% down you would need $38.7K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $1.32M.

Is it a good time to sell my house in Fishers Island, NY?

Yes now is a good time to sell your house in Fishers Island, in May 2026, homes in Fishers Island have decreased in value (price per sqft) by 4% in the last year compared with May 2025.