Homes For Sale in Sheridan Park, Bexley, OH

Currently downstairs unit vacant. Owner just remodeled both bathrooms 2026. New concrete in 2024. Driveway new blacktop done in 2021, Hardwood floors throughout. New windows in 2018, Located across the street from Capital University. 2nd Floor rent ed for $1350/month. Owner Agent

Timeless, classic beauty meets modern elegance in this huge three-story Bexley charmer! Renovated in 2022, this home combines the style you expect from an original Bexley home with the amenities you desire today. The first floor features a sprawling living area with a refreshed decorative fireplace and spacious dining area with plenty of natural light. The completely renovated kitchen is to die for, featuring floor to ceiling storage for even the biggest pack rats, beautiful marble countertops, a massive island with beautiful farmhouse sink, and updated gold fixtures. Step outside into the big three season room, perfect for your bonus space or mud room! Upstairs you'll find three large bedrooms, along with a fully renovated full bath complete with dual vanities, honeycomb tile floors, and updated bath. The third story features a renovated space with air conditioning mini split, perfect for your play room, home office, or a fourth bedroom! A finished basement rounds out the inside, complete with laundry room, full bath, and additional unfinished storage areas in the utility space. Updated with newer HVAC and tankless water heater! Outside you'll find an easy to maintain back yard with a massive parking pad and a newly built two car garage with an electric heater. Don't miss this opportunity for a beautiful piece of Bexley history, schedule your showing today!

Fantastic turnkey investment opportunity in the highly desirable Bexley School District! This charming all-brick duplex is fully leased and income-producing from day one, with current rents of $850 and $750 per month plus utilities. The location is hard to beat! Enjoy easy access to Schneider Park, Bexley Community Gardens, the Jewish Community Center, nearby dog park, and walking and biking trails, while still being within walking distance of the restaurants, shops, and amenities along Bexley's Main Street. Capital University is also nearby, and convenient highway access makes getting around Columbus a breeze. The property features updated living spaces, a yard, and convenient off-street parking. Its classic brick construction offers timeless curb appeal, while the combination of green space, walkability, and proximity to Bexley amenities helps support strong long-term rental appeal. With both units already occupied and tenants paying their own utilities, this is an excellent opportunity to add an established, income-producing duplex in a sought-after location to your investment portfolio!

Fantastic investment or owner-occupant opportunity in the highly desirable Bexley School District! This charming all-brick duplex is vacant, updated, and ready for new tenants--giving the next owner the flexibility to select tenants and establish rents from day one. The location is hard to beat! Enjoy easy access to Schneider Park, Bexley Community Gardens, the Jewish Community Center, nearby dog park, and walking and biking trails, while still being within walking distance of the restaurants, shops, and amenities along Bexley's Main Street. Capital University is also nearby, and convenient highway access makes getting around Columbus a breeze. Both units offer comfortable, updated living spaces along with a yard and convenient off-street parking. The classic brick exterior provides timeless curb appeal and low-maintenance durability, while the combination of green space, walkability, and proximity to Bexley amenities adds tremendous rental appeal. Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or live in one unit while renting the other, this turnkey duplex offers an exceptional combination of location, flexibility, and potential!