Movoto Real Estate
Sold on 12/12/2025
  • Exterior
  • Other
  • Entry Way
  • Living
  • Dining
  • Kitchen
  • Bath
  • Bedroom

5474 Route 23, Windham, NY 12496

  • $950,000

    Last sold 12/12/2025 after 837 Days

  • 7

    bed

  • 3

    bath

  • 4,281

    Sqft ($222/Sqft)

House not for sale
Learn about Windham's top local Real Estate agents

About 5474 Route 23

Property type House
Neighborhood
Year built 1840
HOA fee $0/month
Lot size 2.3 Acre
Movoto estimate
Property description
This large historic home is the original site of Windham's first settler in 1785 and the Reynolds have been entertaining family & friends there since 1959!Located on the west side of town, it is an easy walk to Windham's shops & restaurants.It has a formal living room, (which has been used for an office and playroom), a large dining area and a large, comfortable family room. The kitchen is well designed for many chefs working together - lots of stations! The updated kitchen has wide-plank floors, granite countertops, stainless-steel appliances (including a wine refrigerator), 2 sink areas and a pot filler! There is a mud room with laundry and an additional room off of the kitchen that makes a great playroom or office.The home has 7 bedrooms plus 2 summer bedrooms (no heat). There are 2 storage rooms, outside sheds and a large wrap around porch with a great yard that is perfect for play and entertaining. There is plenty of parking. The home is being sold mostly furnished.
Listed by
Listing Agent - Jane Reynolds
Listing Office - Jane H. Reynolds
Source: Hudson Valley Catskill Region MLS mls logo
MLS#149640 • last updated 1 month ago
Movoto checked Hudson Valley Catskill Region MLS for data 11 minutes ago
Overview
Heating Oil
Levels/Style 2, Two, Traditional
MLS # 149640
SubType Single Family Residence
SqFt 4281
Status Closed
Lot Size (Acres) 2.3
Lot Size (SqFt) 100188
Property Tax 5257
Year Built 1840
Interior
Total # of Bathrooms 3
# of Full Baths 3
Total # of Bedrooms 7
Total # of Rooms 20
Flooring Carpet, Hardwood, Wood
Appliances Other, Water Heater, Washer, Refrigerator, Range, Microwave, Dryer, Disposal, Dishwasher
Interior Features High Speed Internet
Exterior
Roof Asphalt, Shingle
Foundation Block, Concrete Perimeter, Stone
Construction Frame, Vinyl Siding, Other
Parking Carport
Patio/Porch Porch
Other Structures Outbuilding, Shed(s)
Amenities / Utilities
Water Source Well
Location
View Mountain(s), Neighborhood
Area Windham
Community Features Sidewalks, Street Lights
High School District Wind-Ash-Jewett
APN 78.18-1-28
Zoning Residential
Lot/ Land Details
Road Surface Paved
$1M
Range: $908K-$1.11M
Last 30 days 
  • Jul 2026
    mls logo MLS # 149640
  • Jul 2, 2026 Sold
    $950,000 (-4.9%)
  • Jan 6, 2026 Pending
  • Aug 28, 2023 Listed
    $999,000
  • 5474 Route 23
    $950K
  • Windham
  • 12496
    $569K -14% y/y
  • Windham
    $569K -14% y/y
No chart available
Statistics calculated by Movoto
Est. value Bed/bath Sqft mi
5474 State Route 23, Windham, NY 12496 $1,008,000 8/3 4,281 0
5486 State Route 23, #2, Windham, NY 12496 $457,000 3/1 920 0.03
5469 State Route 23, #1, Windham, NY 12496 $511,000 3/2 2,036 0.05
5486 State Route 23, #1, Windham, NY 12496 $336,000 2/1 825 0.05
5465 State Route 23, Windham, NY 12496 $719,000 3/2 3,202 0.05
5473 State Route 23, Windham, NY 12496 $225,000 1/1 476 0.06
74 Thunderbird Ter, Windham, NY 12496 $1,440,000 4/3 4,100 0.06
5461 State Route 23, Windham, NY 12496 $686,000 3/1 2,887 0.06

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.

Thinking of selling? Get a Cash Offer.

  • A smooth, fast sale
  • Skip staging and repairs
  • No strings attached
Source: GreatSchools.org © 2026. All rights reserved.

Around Windham

Explore everything this neighborhood has to offer.
By entering my info and clicking Ask a Question below, I am providing my e-signature and express written consent to receive marketing emails, calls, and texts (including via automatic telephone dialing systems, AI generative, artificial or pre-recorded voice technology) relating to my inquiry from Movoto (and parties calling/messaging on their behalf) even if my number appears on the company, state, or national Do Not Call Registry. You also agree to ourTerms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. Consent not required to receive services (call 1-844-420-1270 to be connected without providing consent).

Nearby recently sold homes in Windham, NY

Nearby homes for sale in Windham, NY

Newest listings in 12496

  • Real Estate
  • NY
  • Greene County
  • Windham
  • 12496
  • 5474 Route 23
Meet with a real estate agent today (844) 430-0869
The multiple listing information is provided by Hudson Valley Catskill Region MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed to be accurate. Buyer to verify all information. The information provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Listing information updated every 15 minutes. Terms of use & Privacy Policy, California Privacy Info. Copyright © 2005 - 2026 Movoto, Inc. All rights reserved. Equal Housing Opportunity CalDRE CalDRE #01517281
Movoto Real Estate is committed to ensuring accessibility for individuals with disabilities. We are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone. We welcome feedback and accommodation requests, please submit them here.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Hudson Valley Catskill Region MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Copyright 2026 by the Hudson Valley Catskill Region MLS. All Rights Reserved. Fair Housing Notice
Standardized Operating Procedures for the Prerequisites Prospective Homebuyers: (1) Perspective clients will not be required to verify their identity during the home purchase process by providing government issued identification. (2) An exclusive broker agreement will not be required on an individual property basis. Or, a specific period of time in order to assist perspective home buyers. (3) In the event a home buyer will be using a mortgage loan to facilitate the purchase of a property. The home buyer will be required to provide proof of pre-approval. (4) In the event the perspective home buyer will be purchasing in all cash. The buyer will be required to provide proof of funds before the submission of an offer.
Requests for information regarding mortgage products will be directed to Movoto.com affiliate, Lower, LLC - a licensed Mortgage Lender (NMLS #1124061), or, based on your location, may be redirected to a participating mortgage marketing partner that may pay Lower, LLC for any consumer contact information provided through this site.