About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

33 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580

$485,500

Last sold 05/11/2026 after 69 Days

4
bed
2
bath
2,605
Sqft ($186/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 33 Dunning Ave

Property type House

Year built 1900

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 0.4 Acre

Movoto estimate

Parking 2 garage spaces

Property description

Circa 1890 Village Gem — Beautifully Updated and thoughtfully maintained! Step into timeless charm with this meticulously upgraded village home blending historic character with modern convenience. The custom cherry kitchen features granite countertops and a Sub-Zero refrigerator, offering both elegance and functionality. Original details shine throughout, including ornate hardwood flooring and stunning leaded glass windows. A newly completed first-floor laundry adds everyday ease. Enjoy relaxing mornings on the covered front porch or entertain outdoors surrounded by extensive hardscape and a beautiful paver patio. A short walk to schools and Websters historic downtown shops and cafe's! The impressive 2-story carriage house provides space for 2 cars, a workshop, and a finished second-floor loft studio — perfect for a home office, art studio, or guest retreat. Many updates throughout (see list of recent improvements) — move-in ready while preserving its historic charm. Open House Saturday 3/7 from 11–1. Delayed negotiations, offers due Monday March 9 @ 12pm. 2605 sq.ft. per appraisal.

Listed by

Listing Agent - John M. Denniston

Listing Agent Contact: 585-704-0749

Listing Office - Hunt Real Estate ERA/Columbus

Source: NYSAMLS’s

MLS#R1664672 • last updated 4 months ago

Movoto checked NYSAMLS’s for data 15 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	HeatPump, Zoned
Heating	Electric, Gas, HeatPump, Zoned, HotWater, MultipleHeatingUnits, Radiators
Levels/Style	Colonial, HistoricAntique
Virtual Tour	N/A
MLS #	R1664672
SqFt	2605
SubType	Single Family Residence
Status	Closed
Lot Size (SqFt)	17424
Lot Size (Acres)	0.4
Property Tax	7207
Tax Assessed Value	137800
Condition	Resale

Interior
Total # of Bathrooms	2
# of Full Baths	1
# of Half Baths	1
Total # of Bedrooms	4
Basement	Full
Total # of Rooms	9
Laundry	Main Level
Flooring	CeramicTile, Hardwood, Tile, Varies
Interior Features	SeparateFormalDiningRoom, EntranceFoyer, SeparateFormalLivingRoom, GraniteCounters, KitchenIsland, Library, Pantry, Storage, SolidSurfaceCounters, Workshop
Window Features	StormWindows, ThermalWindows, WoodFrames

Exterior
Foundation	Block, Stone
Roof	Architectural, Shingle
Construction	BlownInInsulation, Stone, VinylSiding, CopperPlumbing
Parking	Detached, Garage, GarageDoorOpener
# of Garage Spaces	2
Exterior Features	Blacktop Driveway
Lot Desc	NearPublicTransit, Rectangular, RectangularLot, ResidentialLot
Other Structures	Barns, Outbuilding

Amenities / Utilities
Appliances	BuiltInRefrigerator, Dryer, Dishwasher, Disposal, GasOven, GasRange, GasWaterHeater, Microwave, TanklessWaterHeater, Washer
Utilities	CableAvailable, ElectricityConnected, HighSpeedInternetAvailable, SewerConnected, WaterConnected
Sewer/ Septic	Connected
Electricity	Circuit Breakers
Water Source	Connected, Public

Location
Subdivision	Dunning's Sub
High School District	Webster
APN	265401-080-100-0003-032-000

Lot/ Land Details
Road Frontage	City Street

$463K

Range: $412K-$513K

Last 30 days

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

May 2026
MLS # R1664672
May 18, 2026 Sold
$485,500 (+21.7%)
Mar 10, 2026 Pending
—
Mar 3, 2026 Listed
$399,000

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2021
$6,154 +119.6%

$137,800
2018
$2,802 -47.9%

$137,800
2016
$5,377

$137,800

33 Dunning Ave
$485K
—
14580
$359K -1% y/y
Webster
$359K -2% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
39 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580	$513,000	4/2	3,838	0.01
25 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580	$340,000	3/2	1,685	0.01
45-47 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580	$416,000	5/2	2,481	0.02
19 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580	$351,000	3/2	1,862	0.03
30 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580	$424,000	4/1	2,520	0.03
54 Elm St, Webster, NY 14580	$365,000	3/1	2,344	0.03
48 Dunning Ave, Webster, NY 14580	$347,000	3/1	1,792	0.04
50 Elm St, Webster, NY 14580	$435,000	3/1	2,580	0.04

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.