South Whitley, IN Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Welcome to 205 S Fosler Avenue, a charming ranch on a basement nestled on a quiet street in the heart of South Whitley! This home offers a fantastic opportunity to add your personal touches while enjoying the peace of mind that comes with numerous major updates completed within the last five years. Recent improvements include a newer furnace and A/C, all-new electrical and plumbing, updated windows, water heater, water softener, and flooring—taking care of many of the big-ticket improvements! The main floor features two bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a functional layout designed for comfortable everyday living, while the basement provides additional space for storage or future possibilities. Step outside to a spacious, fully fenced backyard, perfect for entertaining, pets, or simply enjoying the outdoors, along with the convenience of a detached garage. All appliances stay, including a stove new in 2023 and a refrigerator, washer, and dryer new in 2025! Located within walking distance of Whitko schools and just minutes from local parks and everything South Whitley has to offer, this home also provides easy access to Warsaw, Fort Wayne, and Columbia City. With major updates already completed and room to make it your own, this property is full of potential and ready for its next chapter! Home is being sold AS IS.

Looking for affordable housing or an investment property in South Whitley? Here is a house for you. This sturdy, all block home is looking for a new owner. This is an estate home that has been used solely as a rental. Above ground pool, deck, pergola and playset belong to tenant and do not remain with the property.

Position your business in the heart of downtown South Whitley with this beautifully renovated commercial property offering approximately 1,260 square feet of versatile space. Thoughtfully updated while maintaining its inviting character, the building features tall ceilings, abundant natural light, and an open, flexible layout that can accommodate a variety of business concepts. Most recently utilized as a production facility and tasting room, the property offers excellent potential for retail, caf or coffee shop, restaurant, professional office, studio, showroom, or other creative commercial uses. The space also includes a modern restroom, convenient rear access for staff and deliveries, and a clean, dry basement providing valuable additional storage. With its move-in-ready condition, downtown setting, and adaptable floor plan, 110 S State Street presents an excellent opportunity for an owner-user, entrepreneur, or investor looking to establish a presence in South Whitley. Bring your vision and take advantage of a renovated commercial space ready for its next chapter.

Step back in time with this spacious 124 year old home located in the small town community of South Whitley! Built in 1902, this traditional two-story residence offers 1,940 square feet of living space, 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and architectural details that reflect its early 1900s heritage. A large covered front porch welcomes you, while the interior features a beautiful staircase with detailed woodwork, original-style trim, tall windows, and generously sized living areas. The main level includes a living room, family room with a wood-burning fireplace, kitchen, bedroom, full bathroom, and convenient laundry area. Upstairs, you'll find additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom. This home retains much of its traditional character, including wood-paneled walls and older flooring, and would benefit from cosmetic updates and personal touches. For buyers who appreciate older homes and aren't afraid of a little work, this property offers an opportunity to refresh the interior while preserving its original charm. Additional features include a 25' x 24' attached two-car garage with storage space, a partial basement, a manageable 0.14 acre lot, and heating and cooling systems reported to have been replaced in 2021. For those who appreciate the nostalgia of small town living, the familiar rumble and rhythmic sounds of passing trains add a touch of yesteryear to this historic home's story...... This is an ONLINE Real Estate Auction. All offers must be submitted ONLINE. The current highest bid amount will be available to the public. The MINIMUM starting bid is $105,000. Having moved into a Retirement Community the Seller will review the Highest Offer on Monday, November 23 @ 3pm. There will be Two Open House dates to view the property on Sun. Nov. 8 (1-2 pm) and Sun. Nov. 15 (1-2 pm). <<< Special Note: This is a Cash Sale. The sale of this property may be financed; however, the sale of this property IS NOT CONTINGENT to financing approval.>>> *This is a Pre-Certified Home with 120 Days Warranty provided by the Home Inspection Co. that Seller has provided for the Buyer to view before the auction. **The Contents of the Personal Property in the Home will also be selling Online Starting 11/13.

Don't miss your opportunity to own this piece of Country living. The opportunities are endless with this 1900 square foot home, setting on just under 5 acres of beautiful rolling, wooded, land. This home has 4 bedrooms, and 1 full bath. The home was built in 1880 and will definitely need a lot of updating, but it has had newer vinyl windows installed, vinyl siding, and a metal roof. There is a newer 24x24 detached garage with a loft, and canning cellar.

Welcome home to this move in ready 3 bedroom, 2 bath home in South Whitley! Situated on a corner lot, this property features a beautifully landscaped yard, a large fenced in backyard, and a garden shed. Inside, the open concept layout offers LVP flooring throughout and an abundance of natural light. The kitchen features wood cabinetry, marble tile countertops, a gas range, dishwasher, recessed lighting, and a large window over the sink. A spacious walk-in pantry provides plenty of additional storage. The large dining and living rooms offer comfortable gathering spaces, with a convenient storage closet nearby. The main level also includes two bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a laundry room with the washer and dryer included. Upstairs, enjoy a private primary suite featuring a large walk-in closet and a full bathroom with a stand-up shower and a beautiful antique vanity. Additional features include a one car attached garage, a 7 year old metal roof, a 4 year old furnace, and a 1 year old water heater. With its thoughtful layout, charming outdoor spaces, and major updates already taken care of, this home is ready for you to move in and enjoy!

Are you looking for the perfect location to build your new home or just need some land for agricultural or storage use? This flexible, spacious lot is located just off State Road 205, near South Whitley conveniences! There is a small pond centrally located on the cleared lot. This property is not in South Whitley's sewer district and was approved by the health dept. for a septic system in 2024. Grab your agent and take a look at it!

Welcome home! Whether you’re a first time buyer or looking to downsize, this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath home is full of potential and ready for its next owner! Step inside to find a cozy living room, a functional kitchen with plenty of cabinet space, and comfortable bedrooms. Enjoy peace of mind with a roof that’s only 2 years old and a brand new water heater! The full basement offers additional storage space and plenty of possibilities. Need a place to relax? The enclosed sunroom is perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or unwinding after a long day. Outside, you’ll find a spacious yard with room for outdoor activities, entertaining, or simply enjoying the fresh air. With its affordable price point and convenient single story layout, this home is a great opportunity to make homeownership a reality. Don’t miss your chance to make it yours

Estate home, Selling As-Is. Was used as a rental. 3 bed, 1 bath with one bedroom on main level. Generous size laundry room.

Estate home. Was used as a rental. Selling As-Is. Cute ranch 3 bed, 1 bath home with amazing hardwood floors in living room and bedrooms. Huge family room in basement. One block from the schools.

A Rare South Whitley Find! Beautifully Landscaped Oasis with an Expansive Layout! It is truly rare to find a home that offers this level of space, functionality, and breathtaking outdoor beauty in town. Situated on a generous quarter-acre lot (74 x 149) in Webster's Second Addition, this captivating property immediately stands out with its meticulously curated curb appeal and a vibrant yard filled with a stunning variety of beautiful perennial flowers. Inside, the layout is designed for comfortable living and grand entertaining. The heart of the home is a very large, open great room that offers endless layout configurations. Moving through the main level, a large, sun-drenched 4-season room provides the perfect sanctuary to enjoy panoramic views of your botanical backyard all year long. The home features 4 spacious bedrooms and 1.5 baths, alongside a nice, clean basement that provides excellent storage or a future finished recreation space. Practical features abound, including a large attached garage providing plenty of space for vehicles, a workshop, or seasonal storage. Located less than a mile from both South Whitley Elementary and Whitko Junior/Senior High, Opportunities to own a property of this size, layout versatility, and landscape quality do not come along often in the Whitko School district. Schedule your showing today before this rare home is gone!

Sold Prior to Auction * This property will be offered in 5 Tracts or in any combination. Some opportunities only come once in lifetime. Whether you're looking for a farm to develop a country estate or looking for an addition to your current farming operation, study the opportunity to bid on the tracts individually or combination for a total of 80± acres of proven tillable land in rural South Whitley. Tract 5 features appx. 2.5 acres with the 1,680 sq. ft. home with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, and multiple outbuildings. Join us for any of the Open House/Inspection Dates or request a Property Information Packet for additional information. Don’t let this one pass you by!

Discover the possibilities on 40 beautiful acres where privacy, natural beauty, and open space come together. Set well away from the road at the end of a long lane, this remarkable property offers a rare combination of seclusion and usable acreage, with approximately 20 tillable acres and 20 wooded acres. A natural spring feeds the creek that meanders through the property, adding to its beauty and creating an exceptional setting for those who appreciate the land and all it has to offer. The acreage provides room for livestock, gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying the peace and quiet of your own private retreat. For those seeking a more independent and sustainable lifestyle, there is also the opportunity to grow your own food, raise animals, and create a homestead tailored to your vision. A large barn/outbuilding with 220 electric adds tremendous versatility for livestock, equipment, storage, or agricultural pursuits. The property was formerly home to a successful purebred cow/calf operation from 2006–2018. Inside the home, original hardwood floors add warmth and character, while the spacious updated kitchen features granite countertops, a large center island, and abundant cabinetry. This is a property that truly needs to be experienced in person. Walking the land is the best way to appreciate its natural beauty, privacy, and the many possibilities it offers. Whether you envision a working farm, a private country retreat, or a more self-sustaining way of life, this unique property provides the space and setting to make it your own. Qualified buyers only.

Spacious 4-5 bedroom, 3.5-bath home on 2.4 acres in a peaceful country setting! Built in 2004, this home offers over 2,900 sq. ft. of finished living space with 9-ft. ceilings and a great floor plan. The main-level primary suite features a walk-in closet and private bath with large garden tub. The kitchen offers hickory cabinetry with crown molding, built-in convection microwave, motion faucet, and adjoining dining area. The impressive great room features an 18-ft. ceiling, open staircase, fireplace, and built-in TV and surround sound wiring. Upstairs you'll find 3 additional bedrooms and a full bath. The finished walk-out basement provides even more living space with a rec room, family room, full bath, and additional finished room ideal for an office, hobby room, storage, or other uses. Updates and conveniences include waterproof luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout the main level and basement, fresh professional interior paint, LED lighting, smart thermostat and switches, keypad door locks, wired security system, CAT5 wiring, Kinetico water softener, and an automatic-transfer generator. The LP tank is owned. Need garage or workshop space? In addition to the finished 2-car attached garage, the property features an impressive 32x60 pole barn with concrete floor, electric, water, 12-ft. ceilings, and two 10-ft. overhead doors—plenty of room for vehicles, equipment, hobbies, or a workshop. The property also features an underground dog fence, mature evergreen, pine, spruce, berry bushes, apple, pear and cherry trees, low-maintenance slate landscaping, and tiled downspouts. Located in the Columbia City school district, this move-in-ready country property offers a hard-to-find combination of acreage, living space, finished basement, and a fantastic outbuilding!

BACK ON THE MARKET AT NO FAULT OF THE SELLERS? Welcome to your country retreat! This 3 bedroom, 3.5 bath ranch offers an open concept layout, with walk out basement, and plenty of space for both comfortable living and country pursuits. Situated upon a rural 5.239 acres, the property includes impressive equestrian and homesteading amenities: Horse arena has 3 horse stalls & tack room. Additional amenities include a whole house generator, goat pen, chicken house, pasture area and so much more! Most recent updates completed in the last 2 yrs: shingles, driveway stones, gutters, flooring, ceiling fans, light fixtures, painting inside and outside, and landscaping are just a few updates. With 5.23 acres updated features, and dedicated space for horses and other animals, this ranch style home offers a unique opportunity to enjoy space, comfort and country living all in one location!

Welcome to this nicely updated home in the town of South Whitley! This move-in-ready property offers an impressive list of brand-new improvements, making it an excellent opportunity for today’s buyer. Updates include a new furnace and central air, exterior doors, interior six-panel doors, vinyl plank flooring, carpeting, kitchen cabinets and countertops with a stylish farm sink, bathroom vanity, shower/tub enclosure, toilet, fresh paint, lighting fixtures, ceiling fans, LED wafer lighting, and a new front porch. Replacement vinyl windows add to the home’s comfort and efficiency. The kitchen comes complete with all appliances, and the washer and dryer are also included. With so many updates already completed, you can move in and enjoy without the hassle of major projects. Come take a look at all this nicely refreshed South Whitley home has to offer!

48 HR FIRST RIGHT - Welcome home to this adorable 3-bedroom, 1-bath home nestled on a spacious lot in South Whitley! Thoughtfully remodeled throughout, this home offers the charm of an established home with the fresh, updated feel buyers are looking for. Improvements include new flooring, drywall, carpet, an updated kitchen and bathroom, and a new roof, making this one truly move-in ready. Outside, you’ll love the extra breathing room the double lot provides, whether you’re dreaming of a garden, play space, outdoor entertaining, or simply a little more room to enjoy. The detached garage is a standout feature with two-car parking plus an additional workshop/man cave area offering plenty of space for hobbies, projects, storage, or your own personal retreat. The covered patio may quickly become your favorite spot, perfect for entertaining friends, enjoying your morning coffee or tea, or settling in with a good book at the end of the day. Located just minutes from downtown South Whitley, you can easily enjoy local eateries, community amenities, parks, and everything this charming small town has to offer. With so many updates already completed, a generous yard, and versatile garage space, this home is ready for its next chapter!

GORGEOUS wooded lot in Whitley County in a country setting but very close to town and all of the conveniences. This is the future site of your dream home or an amazing recreational property. Over 6 acres almost fully wooded. Wide beautiful trails, mature trees, winding streams that meander through the property, berry bushes, abundant wild life, and wild flowers. With over 450 ft of road frontage, you have endless options. This property will provide a serene and secluded location to build your dream home, is perfect for camping, exploring, even raspberry picking. Schedule your showing to walk this stunning Nature Retreat today!!