- $1
- 35.1 Acre
43837 Homes For Sale & Real Estate
7 Homes
Auction Date: November 25th at 3:00PM. Parcel #3 5.1 acres with 650' of frontage with an older home, nice shop, a barn and all you need to start that homestead. Bring your goats and chickens; this one would make a sweet horse farm. Nice area behind the buildings for pasture.
Auction Date: November 25th at 3:00PM. Parcel #2 9.2 acres that has 1100' of frontage that could be a building lot, spot for a cabin or just a very affordable hunting spot. Has a small building that sells along with the land. Nice area behind the buildings for pasture.
Auction Date: November 25th at 3:00PM. Parcel #1A,B,C 5.94 acres in three parcels of land with 200' of frontage that will sell together as one lot. A beautiful building lot with some hunting sprinkled in. Access from Gilmore Road.
- $1
- 5.94 Acre
Summary: Auction date: November 25th at 3:00PM. Great opportunity to buy a property that has a wide array of uses, including fixing up an older home, building sites, hunting or farmland. Farms of this size and location do not become available all the time, so take advantage of this one and come bid your price. An older home that needs some updates comes with one of the parcels as well as several nice barn/shop buildings that are included. There is no need to explain the great hunting in this area, but people who know this area know that whitetails and turkeys are ever present. Lots of options on this one, build, fix up the home, hunt or just simply invest and watch your investment grow throughout the years. Minerals have been withheld and will not transfer with the property. Stop in, grab a brochure, and walk around the the property at your convenience. Immediate hunting rights with a down payment day of auction. Sells subject to final survey.
Parcel #1A,B,C 5.94 acres in three parcels of land with 200' of frontage that will sell together as one lot. A beautiful building lot with some hunting sprinkled in. Access from Gilmore Road.
Parcel #2 9.2 acres that has 1100' of frontage that could be a building lot, spot for a cabin or just a very affordable hunting spot. Has a small building that sells along with the land. Nice area behind the buildings for pasture.
Parcel #3 5.1 acres with 650' of frontage with an older home, nice shop, a barn and all you need to start that homestead. Bring your goats and chickens; this one would make a sweet horse farm. Nice area behind the buildings for pasture.
Parcel #4 35 acres with 85' of frontage with a very nice area for a cabin or home site and of course this one has trails on it and is a great hunting tract. Plenty of room to grow on this one. Buy with parcel 3 and have even more options!
Enjoy the best of one-floor living in this charming, move-in ready home situated on a spacious, level .75-acre lot in a peaceful country-like setting. This beautifully updated home offers 3-4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a convenient first-floor laundry, and a 1-car attached garage along with an additional 24x28 detached garage. There is a great open concepy floor plan. The large fenced-in backyard offers plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, gardening, pets, or simply relaxing and enjoying the peaceful surroundings. Tucked away on a quiet street you will appreciate the privacy and tranquility without sacrificing convenience to schools and shopping. Beautiful updates, a fantastic lot, and two garages make this property a must-see! One-floor living at its finest!
- $229,900
- 3Bd
- 2Ba
- 1,260 Sq Ft
Country living close to town! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home on 10± acres offers room for gardens, animals, outdoor recreation, and potential mini-farm uses. Located along a peaceful country road less than 10 minutes from Newcomerstown and approximately 15 minutes from Uhrichsville, Dover, and New Philadelphia. The main floor features three adaptable rooms for living, dining, recreation, or a home office, with double doors connecting the living room to a deck extending along the home. The kitchen opens to an extra-large, heated and cooled all-season room with numerous windows and separate exterior entrances. An attached approximately 2-car garage leads into the laundry/mudroom and half bath. Upstairs are two bedrooms with closets, a full bathroom, plus a primary suite with a private bathroom and two closets. The previously finished walkout basement has a double-door entrance and potential for restored living space once moisture issues are addressed. A separate 32’ x 40’ garage/shop includes electric service, a wood burner, two sets of double barn-style doors, separate entry doors, a storage loft, an enclosed storage room, and a partially concrete floor. An 8’ x 10’ storage shed provides additional storage. Geothermal heating and cooling, on-site spring water supply, and a shared driveway. Basement/foundation moisture issues require attention. The spring water system may require updates. The septic system has failed inspection and will require replacement. Seller is offering a $45,000 credit toward these identified issues, with the amount and terms to be established in the purchase agreement.
- $319,900
- 3Bd
- 3Ba
- 2,396 Sq Ft
Open SUN 1-3
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
See More Homes
Adjust filters to expand your search.
1 - 7 of 7 Homes for sale in 43837
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
Explore nearby locations
The prices shown are the median list prices.Dover Homes for sale
$284,900
Canton Homes for sale
$99,000
New Philadelphia Homes for sale
$164,900
Newcomerstown Homes for sale
$151,950
Coshocton Homes for sale
$149,000
Massillon Homes for sale
$140,000
Cambridge Homes for sale
$119,900
Sugarcreek Homes for sale
$379,900
Uhrichsville Homes for sale
$124,900
Minerva Homes for sale
$96,150
Carrollton Homes for sale
$129,900
Navarre Homes for sale
$184,900
Bolivar Homes for sale
$324,450
Strasburg Homes for sale
$339,450
Millersburg Homes for sale
$239,500
Barnesville Homes for sale
$135,000
44663, OH Homes for sale
$189,950
43701, OH Homes for sale
$172,425
43832, OH Homes for sale
$190,000
43812, OH Homes for sale
$149,000
44622, OH Homes for sale
$214,500
44654, OH Homes for sale
$204,000
43725, OH Homes for sale
$159,900
44646, OH Homes for sale
$176,800
44615, OH Homes for sale
$151,000
44708, OH Homes for sale
$199,900
Historic Ridgewood Homes for sale
$317,450
Market Heights Homes for sale
$169,000
Harter Heights Homes for sale
$150,000
Vassar Park Homes for sale
$100,000
Colonial Heights Homes for sale
$169,900
Mount Vernon Homes for sale
$194,900
Northwest Homes for sale
$80,000
West Park Homes for sale
$129,900
Northeast Area Homes for sale
$71,750
Tuscarawas County Homes for sale
$161,400
Guernsey County Homes for sale
$147,000
Stark County Homes for sale
$185,000
Holmes County Homes for sale
$203,950
Muskingum County Homes for sale
$194,500
Coshocton County Homes for sale
$149,000
Harrison County Homes for sale
$215,000
Carroll County Homes for sale
$179,900
Narrow your search
43837, OH real estate market trends
Statistics as of November 2026
$229K
Avg. list price
$157/Sqft
Avg. price/sqft
5
Homes for sale
1,260 Sqft
Avg. home size
21 Days
Avg. days on market
Movoto makes it easy to track market trends in 43837, OH. Whether you’re entering the market or planning your next move, understanding these key metrics can guide smart decisions. Looking for more detailed housing market stats in 43837, OH?
Schools
See all 43837, OH schools.
Ratings provided by 
Frequently Asked Questions about Real Estate in 43837, OH
It is affordable to buy a house in 43837. Buying a home in 43837 is 1% less expensive compared with the national average.
Yes now is a good time to buy property in 43837, in November 2026, homes in 43837 have decreased in value (price per sqft) by 28% in the last year compared with November 2025.
The housing market in 43837 is slowing down. In November 2026, homes for sale in 43837 spent a median of 6 days on the market, a 73% decrease from November 2025 last year.
The best and safest neighborhoods to live in 43837 in November 2026 are Historic Ridgewood, Mount Vernon, Colonial Heights, Market Heights, Harter Heights, West Park, Summit, North Lehman, Fairmount, Vassar Park, Fairgrounds, Souers, Northwest, SWIFT, Westbrook Veterans Memorial Park, Northeast Area, Gibbs Area, Cherry Avenue, Georgeview Estates, SWING
In November 2026, 43837 homes were listed to buy for a median price of $229K, with 25% down you would need $1.41K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $48.5K.
Yes now is a good time to sell your house in 43837, in November 2026, homes in 43837 have decreased in value (price per sqft) by 28% in the last year compared with November 2025.