Open Houses in Mystic Island, NJ
No Homes in this area
There’s no inventory based on your search criteria.
Adjust filters to expand your search.
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
Explore nearby locations
The prices shown are the median list prices.Atlantic City Homes for sale
$234,900
Little Egg Harbor Homes for sale
$399,000
Egg Harbor Township Homes for sale
$350,000
Galloway Homes for sale
$375,000
Tuckerton Homes for sale
$469,900
Toms River Homes for sale
$524,999
Brigantine Homes for sale
$699,000
Pleasantville Homes for sale
$239,900
Manahawkin Homes for sale
$500,000
Whiting Homes for sale
$169,000
Barnegat Homes for sale
$624,895
Absecon Homes for sale
$349,900
Ocean City Homes for sale
$1,357,500
Hammonton Homes for sale
$414,561
Mays Landing Homes for sale
$297,000
Smithville Homes for sale
$374,900
08087, NJ Homes for sale
$399,900
08224, NJ Homes for sale
$299,000
08241, NJ Homes for sale
$624,688
08205, NJ Homes for sale
$369,900
08092, NJ Homes for sale
$592,990
08215, NJ Homes for sale
$294,500
08203, NJ Homes for sale
$699,000
08201, NJ Homes for sale
$336,990
08050, NJ Homes for sale
$569,900
08232, NJ Homes for sale
$230,000
Chelsea Heights Homes for sale
$349,000
Lower Chelsea Homes for sale
$254,900
Venice Park Homes for sale
$359,900
The District Homes for sale
$274,900
Bungalow Park Homes for sale
$349,900
Chelsea Homes for sale
$229,000
North Inlet Homes for sale
$299,450
Waterfront District Homes for sale
$164,950
Mount Pleasant Homes for sale
$225,000
Uptown Atlantic City Homes for sale
$287,000
Ocean County Homes for sale
$499,900
Burlington County Homes for sale
$385,000
Atlantic County Homes for sale
$359,900
Schools
Frequently Asked Questions about Mystic Island, NJ
In September 2026 Mystic Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $475K, The median value of a home listed to buy in Mystic Island in September 2026 was $507 per sqft,
It is expensive to live in Mystic Island. Buying a home in Mystic Island is 1% more expensive compared with the national average.
The best and safest neighborhoods to live in Mystic Island in September 2026 are Venice Park, Bungalow Park, Chelsea Heights, North Inlet, Uptown Atlantic City, Duck Town, The District, Lagoon Island, South Inlet, Lower Chelsea, Chelsea, Mount Pleasant, Downtown Atlantic City, Westside, Monroe Park, Waterfront District, Lake Bay
In September 2026, Mystic Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $475K, with 25% down you would need $3.16K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $108K.