About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

5251 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137

$73,289

Last sold 12/26/2025 after 43 Days

4
bed
2
bath
1,264
Sqft ($58/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 5251 Forest Ave

Property type House

Year built 1952

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 5,009 Sqft

Parking 2 garage spaces

Property description

Charming Cape Cod with Endless Potential! This 4 Bedroom Cape Cod Home Offers 1,264 Square Feet of Living Space and is Brimming with Opportunity! Situated on a Spacious Lot with Newer Roof and Some Windows Have been Replaced. Property Includes a Full Basement and 2 Car Detached Garage. The Interior Provides a Blank Canvas for Your Creative Vision, Ideal for Anyone Looking to Customize and Make it Their Own. With Plenty of Character, this Home is the Perfect Project for those Seeking to Bring their Dream Home to Life! This is a Fannie Mae HomePath Property.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Ceanne M Kerwin

Listing Agent Contact: Ceanne@realtorceanne.com, 440-537-2261

Listing Office - RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Source: MLS Now

MLS#5167041 • last updated 8 months ago

Movoto checked MLS Now for data 5 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	Central Air
Levels/Style	Two, Cape Cod
MLS #	5167041
SqFt	1264
Status	Closed
Lot Size (Acres)	0.115
Property Tax	5774

Interior
Total # of Bathrooms	2
# Full Baths	1
# Half Baths	1
# Bedrooms	4
Basement	Full

Exterior
Construction	Aluminum Siding

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer/ Septic	Public Sewer
Water Source	Public
Pool Desc	Community

Location
Elem School District	Maple Heights CSD - 1818
Middle School District	Maple Heights CSD - 1818
High School District	Maple Heights CSD - 1818

We are not permitted to show value estimates for this property.

Jan 2026
MLS # 5167041
Jan 28, 2026 Sold
$73,289 (+12.8%)
Dec 26, 2025 Pending
—
Nov 13, 2025 Listed
$65,000 (-34.3%)
Mar 2004
MLS # 2107868
Mar 29, 2004 Sold
$99,000
Sep 8, 2003 Listed
$99,000
Mar 2004
Public Records
Mar 26, 2004 Sold
$99,000

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2025
$3,496 -0.6%

$43,090
2024
$3,516 -9.7%

$43,090 +48.48%
2023
$3,895 +6.8%

$29,020
2022
$3,648 -35.9%

$29,020
2021
$5,692 +137.8%

$29,020 +32.03%
2020
$2,393

$21,980 -65.0%
2019
$2,393 -57.7%

$62,800 +185.71%
2018
$5,661 +84.3%

$21,980 -65.0%
2017
$3,072 +15.0%

$62,800 +176.9%
2016
$2,671

$22,680
2015
$2,671 +0.8%

—
2014
$2,649

—

5251 Forest Ave
$73.2K
—
44137
$150K +7% y/y
Maple Heights
$150K +7% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
5255 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$119,000	2/1	772	0.01
5257 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$114,000	2/1	736	0.02
5261 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$118,000	2/1	1,044	0.02
5246 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$123,000	3/1	1,296	0.03
5250 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$231,000	3/2	1,988	0.03
5254 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$248,000	3/2	1,988	0.03
5250 Beech Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$131,000	3/1	1,428	0.03
5258 Forest Ave, Maple Heights, OH 44137	$127,000	3/1	1,248	0.03

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.