About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

Exterior
Kitchen
Other
Dining
Bedroom
Bath
Entry Way
Living

57 Nautilus Dr W, Leonardo, NJ 07737

$1,161,500

Last sold 09/02/2026 after 97 Days

6
bed
5
bath
3,707
Sqft ($313/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 57 Nautilus Dr W

Property type House

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 0.93 Acre

Movoto estimate

Property description

Mother/Daughter! Custom 5BR, 3.5BA home on nearly 1 acre featuring a private 1-bedroom mother/daughter suite with separate entrance, full kitchen, living room, full bath, separate HVAC and interior access. The main home offers a vaulted great room, family room with wood-burning stove, finished basement and primary suite with private balcony. Enjoy your heated in-ground pool, expansive paver patio, deck and fenced yard. A rare opportunity combining luxury, flexibility and exceptional indoor/outdoor living in sought-after desirable Leonardo section of Middletown.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Aaron Tishler

Listing Office - Tishler Realty Group LLC

Source: Monmouth/Ocean MLS

MLS#22615860 • last updated 2 weeks ago

Movoto checked Monmouth/Ocean MLS for data 3 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	3+ Zoned AC
Heating	3+ Zoned Heat
Levels/Style	Custom, Mother/Daughter, Contemporary
Status	Closed
MLS #	22615860
Type	Residential
SubType	Single Family Residence
SqFt	3707
Lot Size (Acres)	0.93
Lot Size (SqFt)	40510.8
Property Tax	16995

Interior
Total # of Bathrooms	5
# of Full Baths	4
# of Half Baths	1
# of Bedrooms	6

Exterior
Roof	Shingle
# of Garage Spaces	2
Parking	Direct Access, Paved, Double Wide Drive, Driveway
Patio/Porch	Deck, Patio
Lot Features	Oversized

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer/Septic	Public Sewer
Water Source	Public
Pool	Heated, In Ground

Location
Subdivision	None
County	Monmouth
Directions	GPS 57 Nautilus Middletown
APN	32-00674-01-00024
Zoning	Single Family

$1.26M

Range: $1.15M-$1.38M

Last 30 days

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Sep 2026
MLS # 22615860
Sep 2, 2026 Sold
$1,161,500 (-10.6%)
Jul 12, 2026 Pending
—
May 28, 2026 Listed
$1,299,900 (+128.9%)
Apr 2010
MLS # 21008296
Apr 30, 2010 Sold
$568,000 (-3.7%)
Mar 2, 2010 Listed
$589,900

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2023
$13,894 -0.5%

$957,400 +19.76%
2022
$13,968 +8.3%

$799,400 +7.76%
2021
$12,902 -1.6%

$741,800 +21.01%
2020
$13,106 +1.6%

$613,000
2019
$12,900 -3.3%

$613,000 +0.36%
2018
$13,340 -1.1%

$610,800 -0.78%
2017
$13,486 +4.1%

$615,600 +0.84%
2016
$12,953 -4.4%

$610,500 +3.74%
2015
$13,551 +3.0%

$588,500
2014
$13,155

—

57 Nautilus Dr W
$1.16M
—
07737
$676K 0% y/y
Leonardo
$719K +20% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
55 Nautilus Dr, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$851,000	4/3	2,294	0.03
59 Nautilus Dr, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$867,000	3/2	1,536	0.03
2 Nautilus Dr, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$736,000	3/2	1,252	0.04
2 Flomar Ave, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$1,196,000	5/4	3,370	0.05
61 Nautilus Dr, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$985,000	4/3	2,668	0.05
4 Nautilus Dr, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$1,109,000	5/3	3,042	0.06
5 Nautilus Dr, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$731,000	3/2	1,516	0.06
238 Concord Ave, Leonardo, NJ 07737	$848,000	4/2	2,386	0.06

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.