14 Long Island Restaurants That Will Blow Your Tastebuds

1. Sometimes It’s Alright To Start With Dessert

Waterzooi
850 Franklin Ave
Garden City, NY 11530
(516) 877-2177
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 425 Reviews. Between the seafood, the savory dishes, and the desserts, you can’t go wrong at Waterzooi. This Belgian restaurants brings flavors from abroad straight to your dinner plate, just make sure you save room for something sweet to end the meal.

2. These Aren’t Just Any Old Sandwiches

Roast Sandwich House
827 Walt Whitman Rd
Melville, NY 11747
(631) 629-4869
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 190 Reviews. Everyone knows there’s a big difference between an “alright sandwich” and a really good one, and Roast Sandwich House has some of the best. One of the local favorites is the gooey, but delicious braised brisket grilled cheese with a side of sweet potato tots. It truly is the perfect combo.

3. You Can’t Go Wrong With Fresh Seafood

Harbor Mist
105 Harbor Rd
Cold Spring Harbor, NY 11724
(631) 659-3888
Yelp: 4 Stars; 58 Reviews. With some of the best seafood on Long Island, Harbor Mist never disappoints. With dishes like a Thai calamari and a pecan crusted tilapia, this joint has become a Cold Spring Harbor staple. They’ve also got a delicious brunch, including typical brunch items with a seafood twist, like their famous seafood crepes.

4. Cozy Seating With A View

Farm Country Kitchen
. 513 W Main St
Riverhead, NY 11901
(631) 369-6311
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 195 Reviews. Overlooking the Peconic River in the heart of Long Island wine country, this BYOB restaurant has something for everyone on their menu. From delicious salads to heavier entrees like the filet and the chicken stella, whatever you end up ordering will have you leaving happy.

5. This Cajun Barbecue Can’t Be Beat

Biscuits & Barbecue
106 E 2nd St
Mineola, NY 11501
(516) 493-9797
Yelp: 4 Stars; 198 Reviews. Nestled in Mineola, Biscuits & Barbecue has made a name for itself as one of the top spots for barbecue on Long Island. With an addictively awesome fried chicken and a jambalaya mac and cheese, this place will always have you coming back for more.

6. With This Place, Who Needs Spain?

Tullulah’s
12 4th Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 969-9800
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 46 Reviews. A hot spot in the Bay Shore food scene, Tullulah’s specializes in tapas and small plate dishes. Most of the menu items are reminiscent of a great America classics, while each has its own unique twist. If it’s your first time through the doors, two things you can’t miss are the truffle arancini and the bread pudding.

7. Who’s Ready For Some Flavor?

New Chili & Curry
106 Woodbury Rd
Hicksville, NY 11801
(516) 932-9180
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 302 Reviews. Sure, it’s small and it’s simple, but the food in this humble establishment is some of the best in the state. Specializing in Indian and Thai dishes, New Chili & Curry packs quite the punch when it comes to flavor. Many would agree that this place has the best Indian food on Long Island, with dishes like the chicken chettinad and the chicken tikka masala driving an awesome menu.

8. Mama Mia! This Food Is Delicious.

The Trattoria
532 N Country Rd.
St James, NY 11780
(631) 584-3518
Yelp: 5 Stars; 10 Reviews. Trattoria has some of the most delicious Italian food in the 631, with an expansive menu full of favorites straight from Italy. Options change on a seasonal basis, but it’s easy to tell that each dish takes full advantage of fresh, high quality ingredients. To top it off, it’s a BYOB place, so make sure you bring an awesome bottle of wine to accompany your meal.

9. Hot Pots Are Here To Stay

Maroni Cuisine
18 Woodbine Ave
Northport, NY 11768
(631) 757-4500
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 110 Reviews. Whether you’re on a first date or celebrating an anniversary, Maroni Cuisine is a great place to have a memorable time. This Northport Italian joint is home to the “Original Hot Pot”, a pot shaped dish that is filled with a 100 year old meat ball and spaghetti recipe. The recipe is older than you are so show some respect.

10. Food With A Flair

Kitchen A Bistro
404 North Country Road
St. James, NY 11780
(631) 862-0151
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 103 Reviews. This cash only St. James favorite brings an artistic touch to every aspect of each meal they serve. Their creative dishes are constantly changing, making it difficult to recommend a single dish. But, believe me, you can trust these guys to deliver a delicious meal.

11. Friendly, Local, And Delicious

Sapsuckers
287 Main St
Huntington, NY 11743
(631) 683-4945
Yelp: 4 Stars; 185 Reviews. Sapsucker’s is a great place to go for a hearty meal. With tons of traditional pub food, as well as a few of their own creations, Sapsucker’s will never let you down. Two of the local favorites are the Mallet Burger and the Alabama Sloppy Hammer, which is basically a short rib and cheese sandwich.

12. Food In Its Purest Form

The Purple Elephant
81 Fort Salonga Rd W Ste 25A
Northport, NY 11768
(631) 651-5002
Yelp: 4 Stars; 55 Reviews. Not only does the Purple Elephant have delicious menu items, they’re extremely conscious of where their food is coming from. With plenty of vegan, gluten-free, and natural options, patrons are sure to taste and feel what makes this restaurant different. A few of the tastiest menu items include the vegan mac attack and the yucca fries.

13.  Sometimes Seafood Tastes Best When It’s Raw

Onsen
597 Montauk Hwy
Oakdale, NY 11769
(631) 567-1688
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 103 Reviews. Onsen is a true hidden gem in the New York area. With a menu full of reasonably priced and unique dishes, Onsen’s chefs consistently deliver, making it one of the best Japanese restaurants on Long Island. If you’re wanting to branch out from the typical sushi rolls you order, try the oyster yaki or the kani cups.

14.  When It Comes To Sandwiches, The More The Merrier

SE-Port Delicatessen
301 Main St.
East Setauket, NY 11733
(631) 751-2432
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 161 Reviews. You’ll never run out of options at SE-Port Deli. This delicatessen has dozens of sandwich options, all delicious in their own way. What might possibly be the best deli sandwich on Long Island, the Gasm consists of a chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, savory bacon, Russian dressing, and coleslaw, all on a garlic hero bun. What’s your go-to for great grub in Long Island? Tell us in the comments below!