About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

49 High St, Edgartown, MA 02539

$3,650,000

Last sold 07/31/2026 after 35 Days

5
bed
3
bath
2,733
Sqft ($1,336/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 49 High St

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1920

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 0.38 Acre

Movoto estimate

Parking 2 garage spaces

Property description

A rare opportunity to create a premier in-town compound in one of Edgartown’s most desirable locations. Set on High Street, just moments from downtown Edgartown, this exceptional 16,000+ square foot lot offers tremendous potential to create a substantial five-bedroom residence while enjoying the convenience and charm of village living. The property currently features a 4 bedroom main house, attached 1 bedroom apartment, and an oversized garage with an attached 556-square-foot barn. The property provides a unique foundation for expansion, renovation, or a thoughtfully designed new build. With its generous lot size and coveted location, 49 High Street presents a rare opportunity to create a legacy property within walking distance of Edgartown’s shops, restaurants, harbor, and village amenities.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Alyssa Halisky

Listing Office - Wallace & Co. Sotheby's International Realty

Source: MLS Property Information Network, Inc.

MLS#73542542 • last updated 1 week ago

Movoto checked MLS Property Information Network, Inc. for data 3 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	None
Heating	Oil
Levels/Style	Cottage
MLS #	73542542
Type	Residential
Status	Closed
SubType	Single Family Residence
SqFt	2733
Lot Size (SqFt)	16460
Lot Size (Acres)	0.38
Annual Property Tax	6822.48
Year Built	1920

Interior
Total # of Bathrooms	3
# Full Baths	3
Total # of Bedrooms	5
Basement	Partial
Total # of Rooms	15
Flooring	Wood
Appliances	Water Heater, Range, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer
# Fireplaces	1
Accessibility Features	No

Exterior
Foundation	Block
Roof	Shingle
# Covered Spaces	2
Parking Desc	Detached, Storage, Off Street
# Parking Spaces	6
# Garage Spaces	2
Exterior Features	Porch, Storage, Outdoor Shower
Patio/ Porch	Porch
Lot Desc	Level

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer	Public Sewer
Water Source	Public

Location
Waterfront	Harbor, Ocean, 1/2 To 1 Mile To Beach, Beach Ownership(Public)
County	Dukes
Community Features	Public Transportation, Shopping, Park, Walk/Jog Trails, Bike Path, Public School
Subdivision	Downtown Edgartown
Elementary School	Edgartown School
Middle School	Edgartown School
High School	Martha's Vineyard Regional Hs
Zoning	R5
APN	3773634
Directions	High Street.

Lot/ Land Details
Road Frontage	Public

$3.8M

Range: $3.57M-$4.03M

Last 30 days

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Sep 2026
MLS # 22603145
Sep 2, 2026 Sold
$3,650,000
Jul 31, 2026 Pending
—
Jun 26, 2026 Listed
$3,995,000
Sep 2026
MLS # 73542542
Sep 2, 2026 Sold
$3,650,000 (-8.6%)
Jul 31, 2026 Active
—
Jun 26, 2026 Listed
$3,995,000

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2025
$6,282 +6.7%

$2,370,500 +2.64%
2024
$5,889 +4.8%

$2,309,500 +3.54%
2023
$5,621 +1.3%

$2,230,500 +21.77%
2022
$5,550 -11.3%

$1,831,800 -3.94%
2021
$6,255 -2.1%

$1,907,000
2020
$6,388 -2.8%

$1,907,000 +12.29%
2019
$6,572 +1.3%

$1,698,300 +1.29%
2018
$6,489 +29.3%

$1,676,700 +18.65%
2017
$5,017 -1.9%

$1,413,100
2016
$5,115

—

49 High St
$3.65M
Edgartown Village Historic District
—
02539
$2.87M -37% y/y
Edgartown
$2.86M -3% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
14 Norton St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$5,736,000	4/4	3,096	0.02
12 Norton St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$6,126,000	4/3	2,932	0.02
18 Norton St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$5,060,000	3/3	2,312	0.02
59 Peases Point Way S, Edgartown, MA 02539	$3,764,000	5/4	2,923	0.02
48 High St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$4,652,000	4/3	2,940	0.03
46 High St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$4,917,000	5/4	2,955	0.03
10 Norton St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$7,860,000	4/4	3,007	0.03
42 High St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$3,245,000	4/3	1,771	0.03

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.