About Home value Property history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

25 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539

$3,522,536
Last sold 04/19/2025 for $3.35M
6
bed
6
bath
3,156
Sqft ($1,061/Sqft)

House not for sale

Learn about Edgartown's top local Real Estate agents

About 25 Simpsons Ln

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1900

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 8,712 Sqft

Movoto estimate

Property description

Nestled in the heart of Edgartown, is this historic residence known as The Lightkeeper’s Inn. This property has five bedrooms, five baths and a separate one bedroom, one bath cottage, on .20 acre. Beautifully decorated in ole Vineyard style, the residence has the island feel of old time Martha’s Vineyard. This 5BD/5BA home sits in the heart of Edgartown close to the waterfront. Known as The Lightkeeper’s Inn, this historic Inn was said to be home to Henry Lyman Thomas, one of the last lightkeepers of the Edgartown Lighthouse. The property is unique in that it offers onsite parking, which is a rarity on Martha’s Vineyard.Currently operated as an Inn, this property may be converted to a single family residence with the required proper permitting and approvals.Located close to Edgartown Ferry, Edgartown Lighthouse, and minutes from N. Water Street, which offers shopping and restaurants.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Greg Hartel

Listing Office - Hartel Realty

Source: MLS Property Information Network, Inc.

MLS#73316704 • last updated 1 year ago

Movoto checked MLS Property Information Network, Inc. for data 5 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	None
Heating	Forced Air, Oil, Electric
Levels/Style	Colonial
MLS #	73316704
Type	Residential
Status	Pending
SubType	Single Family Residence
SqFt	3156
Lot Size (SqFt)	8712
Lot Size (Acres)	0.2
Annual Property Tax	6836
Year Built	1900

Interior
Total # of Bathrooms	6
# Full Baths	6
Total # of Bedrooms	6
Total # of Rooms	6
Flooring	Tile, Carpet, Hardwood
Appliances	Water Heater, Electric Water Heater, Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer

Exterior
Foundation	Slab
Roof	Asphalt/Composition Shingles
Construction	Frame
Parking Desc	Off Street, Stone/Gravel
# Parking Spaces	6
Exterior Features	Patio, Rain Gutters, Garden, Guest House
Patio/ Porch	Patio
Lot Desc	Level
Other Structures	Guest House

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer	Public Sewer
Water Source	Public

Location
Waterfront	Beach Front, Ocean, 1/10 To 3/10 To Beach, Beach Ownership(Public)
County	Dukes
Community Features	Shopping
Zoning	R5
APN	3774049
Directions	From Dock Edgartown-Falmouth Ferry- Take Main St-R On No Water St- L On Simpsons Ln To #25

Lot/ Land Details
Road Frontage	Public

$3.52M

Range: $3.17M-$3.87M

Last 30 days

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Jun 2025
MLS # 73316704
Jun 6, 2025 Sold
$3,350,000 (-4.1%)
Dec 2, 2024 Listed
$3,495,000 (+832.0%)
Feb 2004
Public Records
Feb 19, 2004 Sold
$375,000

25 Simpsons Ln
$3.35M
Edgartown Village Historic District
—
02539
$2.87M -37% y/y
Edgartown
$2.95M -4% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
29 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539	$3,701,000	2/3	1,804	0.01
15 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539	$3,956,000	4/2	2,252	0.01
16 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539	$7,517,000	4/5	3,917	0.02
37 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539	$3,987,000	3/3	1,698	0.02
30 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539	$5,435,000	4/4	4,590	0.02
38 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539	$5,675,000	4/3	2,688	0.03
44 N Water St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$6,419,000	5/5	2,917	0.04
50 N Water St, Edgartown, MA 02539	$6,425,000	5/6	3,052	0.04

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.