- $53,000
- 0.55 Acre
Lots & Land For Sale in Castleton, IN
22 Homes
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Build your dream home on this 1-acre wooded lot located on a quiet no-outlet street, offering privacy and a peaceful setting. Its prime location just minutes from the intersection of Interstate 69 and Binford Boulevard provides quick access to shopping, dining, and downtown Indianapolis. Situated in the highly desirable Washington Township school district and with no HOA restrictions, enjoy the walking ditance from the Nicle Plate Trail. This lot combines convenience, top-rated schools, and the perfect spot to create your future home.
- $99,000
- 1 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Highly desirable location in Washington Township schools near interstate, shopping, and attractions. Building permits are already approved.
- $30,000
- 0.15 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
MOTIVATED SELLER!!! LISTING AGENT OWNED!!! BRING AN OFFER!!! This is the DREAM LOT to BUILD ON. The lot is just under ONE ACRE, with NO NEED TO CUT DOWN TREES. Also, there is GAS, ELECTRICITY, WATER, and SEWER at the street. The land is graded flat, and VERY USABLE. Options for a POOL, POLE BARN, or ENTERTAINMENT CENTER are there!
- $160,000
- 0.94 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
A rare opportunity to own a .25-acre wooded lot in the sought-after Rolling Ridge neighborhood at 3905 Winding Way. Mature trees, natural privacy, and a peaceful setting create a wonderful backdrop for a variety of possibilities. The home to the east is the lot's only immediate neighbor, while a large pond behind the property enhances the sense of privacy and tranquility. Enjoy the best of both worlds with a private, wooded setting just minutes from highly rated schools, shopping, dining, major highways, downtown, and the popular Nickel Plate Trail. Whether you're looking to expand your space, create a private retreat, or simply invest in a desirable established neighborhood, this property offers flexibility and opportunity. This property is being offered separately from the adjacent 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home at 3915 Winding Way. Buyers interested in purchasing both properties should refer to the separate home listing for additional details. MLS ID: 22120010. An exceptional opportunity to add privacy, space, and flexibility in an established and desirable Rolling Ridge neighborhood.
- $59,900
- 0.25 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Four building sites in River Park being sold together with a total approximate acreage of 0.88. Current zoning is D-4 per the Department of Metropolitan Development. Per Citizens Energy Group: 7908 N. Keystone Ave - Water & Sewer Mains need to be extended. 7916 N. Keystone Ave - Water & Sewer Mains need to be extended. 7924 N. Keystone Ave - Water & Sewer Mains need to be extended. 7930 N. Keystone Ave - Water Main needs to be extended. Sewer Main available to tap. Buyer to be responsible for all fees associated with extending and connecting utilities. 7916 N. Keystone Ave - Semi Property Tax - $455.00 7924 N. Keystone Ave - Semi Property Tax - $430.00 7930 N. Keystone Ave - Semi Property Tax - $430.00
- $99,000
- 0.23 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Three building sites in River Park being sold together with a total approximate acreage of 0.81. Current zoning is D-4 per the Department of Metropolitan Development. Per Citizens Energy Group: 7902 N. Keystone Ave - Water Main, Sewer Main and Natural Gas Main available to tap. 7842 N. Keystone Ave - Water Main available to tap. Sewer Main needs to be extended. 7850 N. Keystone Ave - Water Main available to tap. Sewer Main needs to be extended. Buyer to be responsible for all fees associated with extending and connecting utilities. 7842 N. Keystone Ave - Semi Property Tax - $505.00 7850 N. Keystone Ave - Semi Property Tax - $505.00
- $99,000
- 0.23 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
A rare canvas in the Geist area-1.2 acres of elevated, treelined serenity where you can create the home that reflects who you are and how you want to live. No HOA. No architectural rules. No limits on imagination. Bring your own architect and builder to craft something entirely your own. Wake up to soft eastern light filtering through the canopy, with the Upper Fall Creek Trail & Park stretching out across the street like your own private nature backdrop. The lot gently slopes above the road, offering a sense of retreat, privacy, and quiet that's increasingly hard to find. With options for a pool retreat, workshop, or multigenerational haven; it's your vision, your builder, your rules. Utilities (water, sewer, electric) are ready at the street, and the deep lot gives you freedom to place the home exactly where it feels right. Here, lifestyle becomes effortless: stroll to Brickhouse Coffee or Sundae's Homemade Ice Cream, spend weekends at Geist Reservoir or Fort Ben Harrison State Park, and enjoy a smooth commute into Indianapolis. In a market full of restrictions, this property stands apart-privacy, possibility, and pure freedom in one of the area's most desirable natural settings.
- $180,000
- 1.21 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Access to property is through an easement on the south side of the car wash parking lot.
- $440,997
- 2.61 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Ready to build your dream home or investment property? This lot at 2404 E 79th St in Indianapolis offers an incredible opportunity. With ample space and a fantastic location, this land is perfect for new construction. Buyer to perform their own due diligence regarding zoning, utilities, and any potential uses for the property.
- $24,900
- 0.15 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Build your own home on this wooded lot in the River Park Community and live among nature. This lot is also conveniently located minutes from I465 and Keystone at the Crossing where you will find shopping ,restaurants, lodging, and entertainment. In addition your home will be a short walk to the private community park along the White River.
- $45,000
- 0.15 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
This beautiful lot located in the First Devington neighborhood at 4702 Lesley Avenue, is just waiting for you to build your dream home in this established community. A large, wooded lot with mature trees, a creek, and a generous .46 acres combines the tranquility of a small neighborhood with the convenience of nearby shopping, schools, churches, etc. Please note that due to the creek running through the back of the property, a portion of the property is located within a designated flood zone. However, the lot's size and outline provide a great opportunity to build a home that suits your lifestyle at an affordable price. Since clearing of the lot has already begun, it will reduce your site costs. Water and electricity are already on the site and gas is available nearby. This is a rare opportunity to purchase an available lot in a quiet neighborhood near the city.
- $21,500
- 0.46 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Discover the perfect canvas for your vision at 4710 Lesley Ave, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the quiet and established Devington neighborhood. Spanning a generous .41 acres, this expansive vacant lot offers a unique blend of suburban peace and natural beauty on Indianapolis's northeast side. The property is beautifully wooded, providing a lush, private canopy that feels miles away from the city hustle while remaining conveniently close to local amenities. What truly sets this lot apart is the scenic creek meandering through the grounds, offering a serene backdrop and a touch of local wildlife right at your doorstep. Please note that due to the creek's presence, the property is located within a designated flood zone; however, for the right buyer with a creative eye, this is an incredible opportunity to design a custom elevated build or a tranquil recreational retreat. Whether you're looking to invest or build something truly unique, this lot offers unmatched character and potential in a friendly residential setting.
- $9,500
- 0.41 Acre
$3K
- $79,000
- 0.19 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Great opportunity to build a custom home in Indian Lake on this 1.01 acre lot.
- $100,000
- 0.89 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
A peaceful, private, wooded 7.76-acre property with rolling terrain and a meandering creek within the city of Fishers. Great setting and ideal place to build your dream estate home. A property like this is hard to find in the city. Please check it out!
- $825,000
- 7.76 Acre
$100K
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Wonderful opportunity to design and build your own Gradison Design & Build custom home in downtown Fishers hottest Neighborhood - South Village of Nickel Plate. South Village is a hip & vibrant Community offering unique Architecture not found anywhere else in Fishers and is located only a 1 Block walk to all things Downtown Fishers & the rapidly growing Nickel Plate Dining/Shopping/Entertainment District + the Nickel Plate Trail. Wonderful opportunity to own your own home and enjoy a fun and active lifestyle where can walk and ride your bike to many activities, stores, restaurants, etc. Fishers District Dining and Entertainment District is a 5 minute car ride away as well. Easy access to I-69 and Interstate.
- $120,000
- 0.09 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
RARE 1+ acre lot for sale in desirable Avalon Hills neighborhood! Just under 1.4 acres for sale off of Johnson Rd across from Skiles Test Nature Park. Build your dream home in the woods with gorgeous mature trees. Walk out and hop on the tails to Skiles Test Nature Park that connect into the Fall Creek Trail. Location right off 465/56th St & Shadeland with easy access to downtown, Broad Ripple and Fishers!
- $365,000
- 1.41 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
Wonderful opportunity to design and build your own Gradison Design & Build custom home in downtown Fishers hottest Neighborhood - South Village of Nickel Plate. South Village is a hip & vibrant Community offering unique Architecture not found anywhere else in Fishers and is located only a 1 Block walk to all things Downtown Fishers & the rapidly growing Nickel Plate Dining/Shopping/Entertainment District + the Nickel Plate Trail. Wonderful opportunity to own your own home and enjoy a fun and active lifestyle where can walk and ride your bike to many activities, stores, restaurants, etc. Fishers District Dining and Entertainment District is a 5 minute car ride away as well. Easy access to I-69 and Interstate.
- $145,000
- 0.12 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
The Sanctuary, is a beautiful wooded enclave and an outstanding hillside community comprised of 21 premium lots; just minutes away from "the rest of the world". Access to shopping, downtown, interstate, and the north side is very simple.
- $139,900
- 0.54 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
The Sanctuary, is a beautiful wooded enclave and an outstanding hillside community comprised of 21 premium lots; just minutes away from "the rest of the world". Access to shopping, downtown, interstate, and the north side is very simple.
- $129,900
- 0.77 Acre
Castleton, IN Homes for Sale
The Sanctuary, is a beautiful wooded enclave and an outstanding hillside community comprised of 21 premium lots; just minutes away from "the rest of the world". Access to shopping, downtown, interstate, and the north side is very simple.
- $69,900
- 0.38 Acre
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
See More Homes
Adjust filters to expand your search.
1 - 22 of 22 Properties for sale in Castleton, IN
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
Explore nearby locations
The prices shown are the median list prices.Indianapolis Homes for sale
$399,900
Fishers Homes for sale
$447,500
Carmel Homes for sale
$550,000
Noblesville Homes for sale
$430,000
Greenwood Homes for sale
$363,990
Greenfield Homes for sale
$292,977
Avon Homes for sale
$429,000
Westfield Homes for sale
$519,900
Brownsburg Homes for sale
$365,000
Speedway Homes for sale
$259,950
Zionsville Homes for sale
$600,000
Fortville Homes for sale
$370,000
Cicero Homes for sale
$306,450
Mccordsville Homes for sale
$466,990
Lawrence Homes for sale
$289,900
Pendleton Homes for sale
$348,000
46226, IN Homes for sale
$175,500
46250, IN Homes for sale
$349,450
46227, IN Homes for sale
$239,900
46240, IN Homes for sale
$347,450
46237, IN Homes for sale
$299,900
46217, IN Homes for sale
$268,950
46260, IN Homes for sale
$364,950
46256, IN Homes for sale
$349,700
46228, IN Homes for sale
$299,000
46235, IN Homes for sale
$269,490
Bridgewater Club Homes for sale
$695,000
River Glen Homes for sale
$519,999
Wildwood Estates Homes for sale
$332,500
Lake Stonebridge Homes for sale
$830,000
Crooked Stick Estates Homes for sale
$1,299,000
The Hawthorns Homes for sale
$1,950,000
Plum Creek Homes for sale
$575,000
Admirals Landing Homes for sale
$382,700
Hancock County Homes for sale
$374,448
Hamilton County Homes for sale
$484,900
Marion County Homes for sale
$265,000
Narrow your search
Schools
Frequently Asked Questions about Castleton, IN
In November 2026 Castleton homes were listed to buy for a median price of $180K, The median value of a home listed to buy in Castleton in November 2026 was $115 per sqft,
It is affordable to live in Castleton. Buying a home in Castleton is 0% less expensive compared with the national average.
The best and safest neighborhoods to live in Castleton in November 2026 are The Hawthorns, Crooked Stick Estates, Lake Stonebridge, Gray Eagle, Bridgewater Club, Thorpe Creek, Plum Creek, Brookshire Village, Brookshire, Saxony, River Glen, Bluestone, Centennial, Admirals Landing, Geist Woods, The Orchards at Sunblest, Wildwood Estates, Muir Woods, The Retreat Condominiums, Conner Creek
In November 2026, Castleton homes were listed to buy for a median price of $180K, with 25% down you would need $1.01K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $34.8K.