Movoto Real Estate

Shelter Island, NY, Market Trends

  • There are 30 active listings and 5 new listings in Shelter Island, NY.
  • In Shelter Island, NY, homes sold for a median price of $2,464,500 in October 2026.
  • On average, properties in Shelter Island, NY sell after 122 days on the market compared to 160 days last year.
  • 24 homes were sold in Shelter Island, NY in October 2026, up from 16 last year.
  • Shelter Island, NY is part of the Suffolk County R-1 School District, with 1 Elementary School, 1 Middle School, and 1 High School.
Show More

Shelter Island Overview

Active Homes
30
See Active Homes
New Homes
5
See New Homes
Open Houses
1
See Open Houses
Price Reduced
4
See Price Reduced
Shelter Island, NY Market Trends & Statistics
last updated on November 2, 2026

Schools in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island, NY hosts 1 public school with an average rating of 5 of out 10 by GreatSchools.

School Districts
1
Elementary Schools
1
Middle Schools
1
High Schools
1
Shelter Island School
public School, Grades PK, K-12
GreatSchools Rating: 5 out of 10

Browse School Districts

Shelter Island Union Free School District

Shelter Island, NY Property Insights

People

People

55% Female/Male
Avg Age is 45 Years Old
School

School

56% with College Degree
99% with High School Diploma
Earnings

Earnings

Avg Household Earnings $120K
1% in Poverty
Elevation

Elevation

26.01 Feet

Tree Coverage

Tree Coverage

57.01%

Average Tree Covering
November Temperature

November Temperature

45° Fahrenheit

H: 53°F   L: 37°F
Days of Sunshine

Days of Sunshine

Low

Compared with the National Average
Rainfall

Rainfall

23 Inches

Recently Listed Homes in Shelter Island, NY
Open Houses in Shelter Island, NY

Nearby Real Estate

Cities
ZIP Codes
Counties
Meet with a real estate agent today (844) 417-0593
  • Movoto Logo
  • Download IOS APP Download Android APP
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed to be accurate. Buyer to verify all information. The information provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Listing information updated every 15 minutes. Terms of use & Privacy Policy, California Privacy Info. Copyright © 2005 - 2026 Movoto, Inc. All rights reserved. Equal Housing Opportunity CalDRE CalDRE #01517281
Movoto Real Estate is committed to ensuring accessibility for individuals with disabilities. We are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone. We welcome feedback and accommodation requests, please submit them here.
Requests for information regarding mortgage products will be directed to Movoto.com affiliate, Lower, LLC - a licensed Mortgage Lender (NMLS #1124061), or, based on your location, may be redirected to a participating mortgage marketing partner that may pay Lower, LLC for any consumer contact information provided through this site.