About Home value Property history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

404 Old Quarry Rd, Saint Augustine, FL 32080

$2,550,000
Last sold 03/27/2025
4
bed
4
bath
3,699
Sqft ($689/Sqft)

House not for sale

Movoto is helping 45 homebuyers near you

About 404 Old Quarry Rd

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1917

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 1.99 Acre

Parking 1 garage spaces

Property description

In days gone by you would have enjoyed afternoon tea or dinner ($1.50 and $3.00 respectively) at the Buccaneer Lodge and sat on this very porch. Fast forward to 2021 and the magic of this beloved estate is even more enticing. A natural sanctuary lies within this walled compound where live oaks and songbirds happily share the peaceful beauty with the people who will call Little Paradise their new home. With 1.99 acres of mature tree canopy, flowering gardens full of butterflies and bees, sunny lawns. shady retreats and remarkable privacy, only the birds overhead can catch a glimpse of the magic you'll find here. Electric gates swing open revealing a circular brick drive and paths that lead to the house, caretaker cottage/studio and standalone garage. Grounds stretch out in all directions - explore and you'll find a serious lap pool with spa, fountains, waterfal and sun patio, a folly, enviable tree-house for the younger crowd and a lovely window-lined building with fireplace that has

Listed by

Listing Agent - Irene Arriola

Listing Office - One Sotheby's - Downtown

Source: St Augustine St Johns MLS

MLS#194712 • last updated 1 year ago

Movoto checked St Augustine St Johns MLS for data 8 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	Central, Electric
Heating	Central, Electric
Levels/Style	3, Historic
Status	Closed
MLS #	194712
Type	RESIDENTIAL
SubType	Single Family Residence
SqFt	3699
Lot Size Range (Acres)	1+ Acres
Lot Size (Acres)	1.99
Taxes	16894
Year Built	1917
Short Sale (Y/N)	No
New Construction Y/N	No

Interior
Bathrooms	4
Master Bathroom	Tub/Shower Separate
# Bedrooms	4
Dining Room	Formal
Flooring	Tile, Wood

Exterior
Construction	Frame, Wood
Roof	Metal
Foundation	Crawl, Skirted
Parking	1 Car Garage, Circular Drive
Lot Desc	Irregular, Corner

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer/ Septic	Septic
Water	City, Well
Green Features - Interior	Programmable Thermostat, Tankless Water Heater-Gas
Green Features - Exterior	Light Color/Reflect. Roof
Miscellaneous	Fireplace, In-Law Suite, Partial Fence, Pool In-Ground, Workshop

Location
Location	City
County	St. Johns
Subdivision	Not Assigned-St. Johns
APN	164410-0000
Directions	Anastasia Blvd To Old Quarry Road (immediately Past The Alligator Farm). Go West On Old Quarry And #404 Will Be 3rd Property On The Right. Gate Will Be Open So You Can Drive Right In.
Zoning	OL

We are not permitted to show value estimates for this property.

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Mar 2025
MLS # 2078022
Mar 27, 2025 Sold
$2,550,000
Mar 19, 2025 Listed
$2,895,000
Mar 2025
MLS # 251672
Mar 20, 2025 Sold
$2,550,000
Mar 19, 2025 Listed
$2,895,000
Mar 2025
Public Records
Mar 20, 2025 Sold
$2,550,000 (-11.9%)
Sep 2024
MLS # 241846
Sep 9, 2024 Price Change
$2,895,000 (-1.9%)
May 28, 2024 Listed
$2,950,000
May 2024
MLS # RM2028115
May 28, 2024 Listed
$2,950,000
May 2024
MLS # 2028115
May 28, 2024 Listed
$2,950,000
Nov 2023
MLS # 1257423
Nov 13, 2023 Listed
$2,950,000
Nov 10, 2023 Listed
$2,950,000 (+3.5%)
Nov 2023
MLS # 237122
Nov 10, 2023 Listed
$2,950,000
Jul 2023
MLS # 1223662
Jul 14, 2023 Pending
—
May 21, 2023 Activeundercontract
—
Apr 20, 2023 Listed
$2,850,000 (+35.7%)
Apr 2023
MLS # 231933
Apr 20, 2023 Listed
$2,850,000
Aug 2021
MLS # 1048809
Aug 26, 2021 Sold
$2,100,000
Jul 30, 2021 Pending
—
Jul 11, 2021 Contingent Take Backup
—
Dec 27, 2020 Listed
—
Dec 21, 2020 Contingent Take Backup
—
Nov 30, 2020 Price Change
$2,150,000 (-4.4%)
Sep 2, 2020 Price Change
$2,248,000 (-10.0%)
Apr 15, 2020 Listed
$2,498,000 (+16.2%)
Apr 11, 2020 Listed
—
Aug 2021
MLS # 194712
Aug 17, 2021 Pending
—
Aug 16, 2021 Sold
$2,100,000 (-2.3%)
Mar 26, 2021 Listed
—
Mar 26, 2021 Pending
—
Apr 11, 2020 Listed
$2,150,000 (+120.5%)
Aug 2021
Public Records
Aug 17, 2021 Sold
$2,100,000
Oct 2006
Public Records
Oct 18, 2006 Sold
$975,000

404 Old Quarry Rd
$2.55M
Not Assigned-st. Johns
—
32080
$599K 0% y/y
Saint Augustine
$494K -1% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
1 Park Terrace Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$1,066,000	2/2	1,634	0.03
244 Coquina Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$579,000	3/2	1,470	0.03
402 Old Quarry Rd, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$976,000	3/2	1,992	0.04
2 Park Terrace Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$612,000	3/2	1,629	0.04
3 Park Terrace Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$915,000	4/3	2,997	0.05
4 Park Terrace Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$623,000	3/2	1,841	0.06
405 Old Quarry Rd, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$662,000	3/2	1,634	0.06
245 Coquina Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$900,000	3/2	1,768	0.07

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.