About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

37 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080

$525,000

Last sold 06/16/2025

4
bed
4
bath
2,515
Sqft ($209/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 37 Magnolia Dr

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1915

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 4,792 Sqft

Property description

The former Coquina Inn, in Lighthouse Park neighborhood, a historical treasure offers a unique opportunity steeped in history. Built in 1915 by Mary Heston, the Post Mistress of Anastasia Island. It was once a winter retreat for Arthur Brisbane, Chief Editor of W.R. Hearst. Constructed with Tabby Revival architecture of coquina block, this home embodies cultural significance backed with resilient construction. With 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, & an adjoining apartment with separate entrance. Inside, it features original hardwood floors, 2 fireplaces (primary has hidden nook), crown molding, & beadboard ceilings. 1,700sf unfinished basement with separate entrance, a cistern & other eccentricities. The primary suite is complete with a sitting area & fireplace with a hidden nook. Elevated in Flood Zone X. With a touch of vision & restoration, the grandeur can be revived to live amidst history. 2nd floor hallway light does not convey. Weekly rentals allowed, buyer to verify.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Karen Sederberg

Listing Office - Exp Realty (Deerwood Park)

Source: St Augustine St Johns MLS

MLS#251642 • last updated 11 months ago

Movoto checked St Augustine St Johns MLS for data 41 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	Central
Heating	Central
Levels/Style	2 Level, 2, 2 Story, Historic
Status	Conting_Accpt Backups
MLS #	251642
Type	RESIDENTIAL
SubType	Single Family Residence
SqFt	2515
Lot Size Range (Acres)	Less Than 1/4 Acre
Lot Size (Acres)	0.11
Taxes	11956.42
Year Built	1915
Short Sale (Y/N)	No
New Construction Y/N	No

Interior
Bathrooms	4
Master Bathroom	Shower Only
# Bedrooms	4
Dining Room	Formal
Flooring	Wood

Exterior
Construction	Concrete Block
Roof	Metal
Parking	Off Street
Lot Desc	Corner

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer/ Septic	Septic
Water	City
Miscellaneous	Fireplace, In-Law Suite

Location
Location	East Of A1A
County	St. Johns
Community Features	RV/Boat Parking, Tennis
Subdivision	Carver
APN	157350-0000
Directions	Heading South On A1A, Turn Right Onto Busam Street, Turn Left Onto Magnolia Drive, Home Is On The Right
Zoning	RS-2

We are not permitted to show value estimates for this property.

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Jun 2025
Public Records
Jun 16, 2025 Sold
$525,000
Jun 2025
MLS # 251642
Jun 13, 2025 Sold
$525,000 (-16.5%)
May 7, 2025 Price Change
$629,000 (-7.4%)
Apr 25, 2025 Price Change
$679,000 (-2.9%)
Apr 14, 2025 Price Change
$699,000 (-6.8%)
Mar 18, 2025 Listed
$750,000 (-14.3%)
Oct 2024
MLS # 243008
Oct 3, 2024 Price Change
$875,000 (-11.1%)
Sep 5, 2024 Price Change
$984,000 (-1.5%)
Jul 8, 2024 Listed
$999,000 (-16.7%)
Jul 2024
MLS # RM2035968
Jul 9, 2024 Listed
$999,000
Jul 2024
MLS # 2035968
Jul 9, 2024 Listed
$999,000
Apr 2024
MLS # 2018672
Apr 8, 2024 Listed
$1,199,000

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2024
$11,956 +3626.1%

$670,204 +256.79%
2023
$321 +12.6%

$187,841 +3.0%
2022
$285

$182,370 +3.0%
2021
$285

$177,058 +1.4%
2020
$285

$174,613 +2.3%
2019
$285 +39.7%

$170,687 +1.9%
2017
$204 +16.6%

$167,504 +1.21%
2016
$175 +20.9%

$165,506
2015
$145

—

37 Magnolia Dr
$525K
Carver
—
32080
$595K 0% y/y
Saint Augustine
$487K 0% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
27 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$925,000	4/2	2,176	0.01
28 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$404,000	2/1	736	0.02
30 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$516,000	2/1	646	0.02
31 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$713,000	2/1	764	0.02
26 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$389,000	3/—	656	0.03
9 Palmetto Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$362,000	2/1	919	0.03
23 Magnolia Dr, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$882,000	3/3	1,905	0.03
15 Palmetto Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32080	$361,000	2/1	902	0.03

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.