About Home value Property history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

17 May St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084

$350,000
Last sold 07/25/2025
3
bed
2
bath
1,516
Sqft ($231/Sqft)

House not for sale

Movoto is helping 45 homebuyers near you

About 17 May St

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1935

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 0.27 Acre

Rental estimate

Property description

Presiding under a stately live oak canopy, this circa 1935 cottage lives larger than it looks from the sidewalk. Sitting squarely in the center of a 1/4+ acre lot, the front, back and side yards offer abundant outdoor entertaining areas along with driveways on both May St and E San Carlos Ave. Enclosed front porch is now a sun room with early morning light and a golden glow in late afternoon. A short foyer leads to a generous living room where a gas fireplace patiently waits for cool nights.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Irene Arriola

Listing Office - One Sotheby's - Downtown

Source: St Augustine St Johns MLS

MLS#188069 • last updated 1 year ago

Movoto checked St Augustine St Johns MLS for data 20 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	Central, Electric
Heating	Central, Electric
Levels/Style	1, Cottage, Traditional
Status	Closed
MLS #	188069
Virtual Tour	N/A
Type	RESIDENTIAL
SubType	Single Family Residence
SqFt	1516
Lot Size Range (Acres)	1/4 To 1/2 Acre
Lot Size (Acres)	0.27
Taxes	2011
Year Built	1935
Short Sale (Y/N)	No
New Construction Y/N	No

Interior
Bathrooms	2
Master Bathroom	Shower Only
# Bedrooms	3
Dining Room	Formal
Flooring	Tile, Vinyl, Wood

Exterior
Construction	Frame, Wood
Roof	Metal
Foundation	Crawl, Skirted
Parking	Off Street, Other-See Remarks
Lot Desc	Regular

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer/ Septic	Sewer
Water	City
Green Features - Exterior	Light Color/Reflect. Roof
Miscellaneous	Auto Sprinkler, Fireplace, Full Fence, Insulated Windows

Location
Location	City
County	St. Johns
Subdivision	Nelmar Terrace
APN	153940-0000
Directions	From San Marco Ave Go East On May St To Magnolia Ave. Go South On Magnolia And Immediately West On E San Carlos. Proceed Till You See Sign On The Right And Pull Into Driveway.
Zoning	RS-1

We are not permitted to show value estimates for this property.

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Jul 2025
MLS # 188069
Jul 25, 2025 Sold
$350,000
Jun 14, 2019 Listed
$375,000 (+108.3%)
Jan 2024
MLS # 1020792
Jan 19, 2024 Sold
$350,000
Jun 14, 2019 Listed
—
Oct 2019
Public Records
Oct 16, 2019 Sold
$350,000 (-6.7%)
Apr 2010
Public Records
Apr 7, 2010 Sold
$180,000 (+46.6%)
Mar 2001
Public Records
Mar 29, 2001 Sold
$122,800

17 May St
$350K
Nelmar Terrace
—
32084
$389K -3% y/y
Saint Augustine
$489K -2% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
19 May St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$321,823	3/1	1,168	0.01
15 May St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$459,820	3/2	2,011	0.02
14 E San Carlos Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$345,863	3/2	1,432	0.03
29 E San Carlos Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$303,274	2/1	775	0.03
21 May St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$421,332	3/2	1,467	0.03
33 E San Carlos Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$704,083	3/2	1,530	0.03
18 May St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$370,875	2/—	1,356	0.04
16 May St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084	$890,267	4/4	4,495	0.04

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.