Last updated November 16, 2026
The median home price in 11964 is $2,495,000, down 21.4% year-over-year. Median price per square foot is down 4.0% at $832/sq. ft. Homes are selling in 125 days on average, compared to 160 days last year. As of November 16, 2026, there are 25 active listings on the market, with 1 new listing in the last 7 days.
Median home price
$2.5M
21.4% YoY
YoY price change
-21.4%
-$680,000
Days on market
125
-35 days YoY
Active homes
25
56.3% YoY
$2,495,000
25
$832
125 days
3,072 sqft
Select a district to view it's schools.
Shelter Island Union Free School District has 1 high school, 1 middle school, and 1 elementary school. It has an overall average GreatSchools rating of 5/10.