About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

Exterior
View/Area
Other
Living

5271 E Willow Ct, Monticello, IN 47960

$420,000

Last sold 03/17/2026 after 162 Days

4
bed
3
bath
2,016
Sqft

House not for sale

About 5271 E Willow Ct

Property type House

Neighborhood

Year built 1977

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 0.39 Acre

Movoto estimate

Parking 2 garage spaces

Property description

Welcome to this serene lakeside retreat tucked away on desirable Lake Shafer This two-story home blends privacy, comfort, and water views, offering an exceptional setting for everyday living or weekend getaways. Perfect chance to add your paint and flooring. 4 generous bedrooms with ample closet space 2.5 bathrooms, including a large primary suite All measurements are taken from county records buyers are responsible for own measures. Expansive living room with picture windows overlooking the trees and lake Formal dining room ideal for family gatherings Walkout patio and backyard with wooded privacy and lake access potential Attached 2-car garage Quiet cul-de-sac location in a peaceful, established neighborhood Enjoy morning coffee on the deck with calming lake views, or host summer barbecues surrounded by nature. With its mix of open-concept living and private outdoor space, this property offers the best of both relaxation and convenience — just minutes from Monticello shopping, dining, and boating on Lake Shafer. And additional buildable lot included!

Listed by

Listing Agent - Jace Hicks

Listing Office - Summerland Realty Group, LLC

Source: IRMLS

MLS#202540502 • last updated 6 months ago

Movoto checked IRMLS for data 4 minutes ago

Overview
Cooling/AC	Central Air
Heating	Gas
Levels/Style	Two Story
Status	Sold
MLS #	202540502
Virtual Tour	N/A
Type	RESIDENTIAL
SubType	Site-Built Home
SqFt (Total)	2016
SqFt (Finished)	2016
Lot Size (SqFt)	16988
L:ot Size (Acres)	0.39
Foreclosure (Y/N)	No
Year Built	1977
Short Sale (Y/N)	No
HOA Fees $	Not Applicable

Interior
Total # Bathrooms	3
# Full Baths	2
# Half Baths	1
Total # Bedrooms	4
Kitchen	Main
Living/ Great Room	Main
Dining Room	Main
Total # of Rooms	9
Laundry	Main
Fireplace	Den

Exterior
Exterior	Wood
Basement/ Foundation	Slab
Garage	Attached
Lot Dimensions	105X160
Lot Desc	Cul-De-Sac
Other Structure(s)	None

Amenities / Utilities
Sewer	None
Well	Private
Water	Well

Location
Water Frontage (feet)	240
Body of Water	Lake, Lake Shafer
Waterfront	Lakefront
Lake Type	Ski Lake
Area	White County
Subdivision	Lake Shafer
High School	Twin Lakes
Middle School	Roosevelt
Elementary School	Meadowlawn
School District	Twin Lakes School Corp.
APN	91-73-16-000-023.000-020
Waterfront Y/N	Yes
Directions	North On 6th Street Right On Willow Ct.

$421K

Range: $383K-$458K

Last 30 days

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Apr 2026
MLS # 202540502
Apr 20, 2026 Sold
$420,000 (-5.6%)
Mar 17, 2026 Pending
—
Mar 12, 2026 Listed
—
Mar 7, 2026 Expired
—
Feb 26, 2026 Price Change
$445,000 (-0.7%)
Feb 13, 2026 Price Change
$448,000 (-0.2%)
Oct 29, 2025 Price Change
$449,000 (-9.3%)
Oct 6, 2025 Listed
$495,000 (+39.4%)
Dec 2018
MLS # 201848374
Dec 13, 2018 Sold
$355,000 (-5.3%)
Dec 6, 2018 Pending
—
Oct 29, 2018 Price Change
$374,900 (+11.6%)
Oct 29, 2018 Listed
$335,900 (+8.4%)
Oct 2016
MLS # 201505621
Oct 26, 2016 Sold
$310,000 (-7.7%)
Oct 5, 2016 Pending
—
May 24, 2016 Price Change
$335,900 (+405.1%)
May 23, 2016 Listed
—
May 22, 2016 Expired
—
Nov 20, 2015 Listed
—
Nov 18, 2015 Expired
—
Oct 20, 2015 Price Change
$345,000 (+283.8%)
Aug 17, 2015 Listed
—
Aug 14, 2015 Expired
—
Feb 13, 2015 Listed
$359,900 (-20.0%)
Mar 2016
MLS # 201505624
Mar 1, 2016 Sold
$66,500 (-11.3%)
Feb 4, 2016 Pending
—
Nov 20, 2015 Listed
—
Nov 19, 2015 Expired
—
Oct 20, 2015 Price Change
$75,000 (-78.3%)
Aug 18, 2015 Listed
—
Aug 14, 2015 Expired
—
Feb 13, 2015 Listed
$89,900 (-75.0%)
Oct 2011
MLS # 367016
Oct 27, 2011 Expired
—
Apr 26, 2011 Listed
$449,900
Apr 2011
MLS # 20076422
Apr 26, 2011 Listed
—
Oct 2008
MLS # 367026
Oct 1, 2008 Expired
—
Sep 17, 2007 Listed
$449,900

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2025
$6,076 +143.6%

$422,400
2024
$2,494 +20.7%

$422,400 +5.97%
2023
$2,066 -2.4%

$398,600 +9.12%
2022
$2,117 +16.2%

$365,300 +5.79%
2021
$1,823 -52.7%

$345,300 +7.6%
2020
$3,853 +4.2%

$320,900
2019
$3,699 +179.2%

$320,900
2018
$1,325 +12.5%

$320,900 +33.37%
2017
$1,178 +5.9%

$240,600
2016
$1,112

—
2015
$1,112

—

5271 E Willow Ct
$420K
White County
—
47960
$299K -23% y/y
Monticello
$299K -23% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
5259 E Willow Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$652,000	4/3	2,362	0.03
5229 E Willow Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$953,000	3/3	5,286	0.03
5204 E Willow Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$462,000	—/2	2,880	0.04
5205 E Willow Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$404,000	3/2	2,475	0.05
5158 Highland Cove Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$403,000	3/2	1,642	0.09
5174 Highland Cove Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$423,000	3/3	1,810	0.09
5128 Highland Cove Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$599,000	3/2	3,132	0.09
5077 E Willow Ct, Monticello, IN 47960	$263,000	2/1	1,248	0.1

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.