Homes with Foreclosure For Sale in Fire Island, NY
No Homes in this area
There’s no inventory based on your search criteria.
Adjust filters to expand your search.
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
Schools
Fire Island, NY Real Estate Snapshot
List Price
—
$/Sqft
—
Homes For Sale
—
Home Size
— Sqft
Days on Movoto
—
Frequently Asked Questions about Fire Island, NY
In May 2026 Fire Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $1.45M,
It is expensive to live in Fire Island. Buying a home in Fire Island is 3% more expensive compared with the national average.
The best and safest neighborhoods to live in Fire Island in May 2026 are Saugatuck, Shippan Point, Rowayton, The Canals, Presidents Streets, The Walks, East Norwalk, Westholme South, East End North, South Bellmore, East Side, Woodward Avenue, Copiague Harbor, American Venice, The Cove, Brookside, Shippan, Black Rock, East End, South End
In May 2026, Fire Island homes were listed to buy for a median price of $1.45M, with 25% down you would need $8.69K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $297K.
The Movoto Advantage
Movoto gives you access to the most up-to-the-minute real estate information in Fire Island. As a licensed brokerage in New York (and across the United States), Movoto has access to the latest real estate data including Fire Island Homes for Sale, Fire Island Single family for Sale, Fire Island Townhomes/Condos for Sale, Fire Island Multi family/Duplex for Sale, Fire Island Land for Sale, Fire Island New Listings for Sale, Fire Island New Construction for Sale, Fire Island Rentals, Fire Island Apartments for Rent, Fire Island Single Family for Rent, Fire Island Recently Sold Homes, Fire Island Waterfront for Sale, Fire Island Foreclosures for Sale.
Real Estate & Homes For Sale Nearby Fire Island, NY
Cities
- Homes for sale in Bay Shore
- Homes for sale in Patchogue
- Homes for sale in Brentwood
- Homes for sale in Sayville
- Homes for sale in Central Islip
- Homes for sale in Holbrook
- Homes for sale in Bayport
- Homes for sale in Oakdale
- Homes for sale in Deer Park
- Homes for sale in Ronkonkoma
- Homes for sale in East Islip
- Homes for sale in Medford
- Homes for sale in Dix Hills
- Homes for sale in Shirley
- Homes for sale in Islip
- Homes for sale in Bohemia
- Homes for sale in Smithtown
- Homes for sale in West Babylon
- Homes for sale in Hicksville
- Homes for sale in Valley Stream
ZIP Codes
- Homes for sale in 11706, NY
- Homes for sale in 11746, NY
- Homes for sale in 11772, NY
- Homes for sale in 11040, NY
- Homes for sale in 11717, NY
- Homes for sale in 11020, NY
- Homes for sale in 11782, NY
- Homes for sale in 11779, NY
- Homes for sale in 11776, NY
- Homes for sale in 11791, NY
- Homes for sale in 11701, NY
- Homes for sale in 11576, NY
- Homes for sale in 11530, NY
- Homes for sale in 11763, NY
- Homes for sale in 11753, NY
- Homes for sale in 11590, NY
- Homes for sale in 11550, NY
- Homes for sale in 11758, NY
- Homes for sale in 11003, NY
- Homes for sale in 11733, NY
Neighborhoods
- Homes for sale in Black Rock
- Homes for sale in Rowayton
- Homes for sale in Shippan Point
- Homes for sale in Copiague Harbor
- Homes for sale in South Bellmore
- Homes for sale in East Norwalk
- Homes for sale in The Cove
- Homes for sale in Saugatuck
- Homes for sale in South End
- Homes for sale in American Venice
- Homes for sale in The Canals
- Homes for sale in Shippan
- Homes for sale in East End
- Homes for sale in The Walks
- Homes for sale in Westholme South
- Homes for sale in Brookside
- Homes for sale in Woodward Avenue
- Homes for sale in Presidents Streets
- Homes for sale in East End North
- Homes for sale in East Side