Open Houses in Eagle Bay, NY
No Homes in this area
There’s no inventory based on your search criteria.
Adjust filters to expand your search.
Don’t see what you’re looking for?
A local real estate agent is the best way to get access to exclusive and off-market properties so you can find home.
Explore nearby locations
The prices shown are the median list prices.Inlet Homes for sale
$414,450
Old Forge Homes for sale
$259,000
Boonville Homes for sale
$129,900
Lowville Homes for sale
$189,900
Forestport Homes for sale
$175,000
Indian Lake Homes for sale
$359,000
Thendara Homes for sale
$160,000
Brantingham Homes for sale
$2,300,000
Croghan Homes for sale
$192,500
Constableville Homes for sale
$99,500
Ohio Homes for sale
$299,900
Long Lake Homes for sale
$325,000
Greig Homes for sale
$360,000
Lake Pleasant Homes for sale
$464,500
Glenfield Homes for sale
$250,000
Lyons Falls Homes for sale
$139,900
13324, NY Homes for sale
$239,900
13420, NY Homes for sale
$462,500
13309, NY Homes for sale
$94,000
13438, NY Homes for sale
$207,450
13338, NY Homes for sale
$164,950
13360, NY Homes for sale
$414,450
13433, NY Homes for sale
$75,000
13343, NY Homes for sale
$24,500
12986, NY Homes for sale
$90,000
13327, NY Homes for sale
$164,900
Herkimer County Homes for sale
$144,950
Lewis County Homes for sale
$122,950
Hamilton County Homes for sale
$320,000
Narrow your search
Schools
Frequently Asked Questions about Eagle Bay, NY
In October 2026 Eagle Bay homes were listed to buy for a median price of $1.12M, The median value of a home listed to buy in Eagle Bay in October 2026 was $551 per sqft,
It is expensive to live in Eagle Bay. Buying a home in Eagle Bay is 3% more expensive compared with the national average.
In October 2026, Eagle Bay homes were listed to buy for a median price of $1.12M, with 25% down you would need $6.75K/month to cover expenses and assume that's 35% of your total monthly income, your total yearly income would need to be $231K.