About Home value Property history Tax history Market statistics Schools Neighborhood Places of interest

51 Seneca St, Starkey, NY 14837

$237,500

Last sold 01/07/2026 after 174 Days

6
bed
2
bath
3,672
Sqft ($65/Sqft)

House not for sale

About 51 Seneca St

Property type House

Year built 1882

HOA fee $0/month

Lot size 0.35 Acre

Parking 1 garage spaces

Property description

1882 Victorian with 5-6 bedrooms in excellent condition. This home showcases so much history with gorgeous chandeliers, hardwood floors, pocket doors, stained glass, fireplace in the front formal parlor. There's so much to see that only a private showing will allow someone to take it all in. Relax in the backyard from the gazebo surrounded by flower gardens. It's only a short walk to the business district and even closer to the school. Located in the middle of the Finger Lakes it's only a short drive to area wineries, great restaurants on the lake, beaches, Watkins Glen International Raceway, grape vineyards and State Parks. Taxes based on 2024 assessment, the new assessment is $240,000.

Listed by

Listing Agent - Ronald K. Miller

Listing Office - Keuka Lake & Land Realty

Source: NYSAMLS’s

MLS#R1623542 • last updated 6 months ago

Movoto checked NYSAMLS’s for data 3 minutes ago

Overview
Heating	Gas, ForcedAir
Levels/Style	Two, Victorian
MLS #	R1623542
SqFt	3672
SubType	Single Family Residence
Status	Closed
Lot Size (SqFt)	15200
Lot Size (Acres)	0.3489
Property Tax	3946
Tax Assessed Value	240000
Condition	Resale

Interior
Total # of Bathrooms	2
# of Full Baths	2
Total # of Bedrooms	6
Basement	Full, WalkOutAccess
Total # of Rooms	13
Laundry	Main Level
Flooring	Carpet, Hardwood, Tile, Varies
Interior Features	CeilingFans, Den, SeparateFormalDiningRoom, EntranceFoyer, EatInKitchen, SeparateFormalLivingRoom, CountryKitchen, NaturalWoodwork, WindowTreatments, BedroomOnMainLevel
Window Features	Drapes, LeadedGlass, StormWindows, WoodFrames

Exterior
Foundation	Stone
Roof	Asphalt, Shingle
Construction	BlownInInsulation, WoodSiding, CopperPlumbing
Parking	Attached, Garage, GarageDoorOpener
# of Garage Spaces	1
Exterior Features	FullyFenced, Fence, GravelDriveway
Patio/ Porch	Covered, Porch
Lot Desc	Rectangular, RectangularLot, ResidentialLot
Other Structures	Gazebo, Sheds, Storage
Fencing	Full, Partial

Amenities / Utilities
Appliances	Dryer, Dishwasher, GasOven, GasRange, GasWaterHeater, Refrigerator, Washer
Utilities	CableAvailable, ElectricityConnected, HighSpeedInternetAvailable, SewerConnected, WaterConnected
Sewer/ Septic	Connected
Electricity	Circuit Breakers
Water Source	Connected, Public

Location
High School District	Dundee
APN	573401-120-026-0001-014-000-0000

Lot/ Land Details
Road Frontage	City Street

We are not permitted to show value estimates for this property.

Lower your payment with the loan terms that fit you.

Jan 2026
Public Records
Jan 12, 2026 Sold
$237,500
Jan 2026
MLS # R1623542
Jan 9, 2026 Sold
$237,500 (-8.7%)
Oct 28, 2025 Pending
—
Oct 18, 2025 Price Change
$260,000 (-3.7%)
Oct 2, 2025 Price Change
$270,000 (-1.8%)
Jul 17, 2025 Listed
$275,000 (+261.8%)
Mar 2003
Public Records
Mar 31, 2003 Sold
$76,000

Year Property taxes Tax assessment
2025
$6,983 +83.1%

$240,000 +95.92%
2024
$3,814 +221.6%

$122,500
2016
$1,186

$122,500

51 Seneca St
$237K
—
14837
$349K -41% y/y
Starkey
$324K -38% y/y

No chart available

Statistics calculated by Movoto

	Est. value	Bed/bath	Sqft	mi
49 Seneca St, Dundee, NY 14837	$257,000	3/2	2,650	0.02
53 Seneca St, Dundee, NY 14837	$263,000	4/2	3,538	0.02
47 Seneca St, Dundee, NY 14837	$263,000	4/2	2,531	0.03
44 Hollister St, Dundee, NY 14837	$182,000	3/2	1,836	0.04
42 Hollister St, Dundee, NY 14837	$155,000	3/1	1,815	0.04
46 Hollister St, Dundee, NY 14837	$177,000	4/1	1,920	0.04
52 Seneca St, Dundee, NY 14837	$225,000	3/2	3,003	0.04
48 Hollister St, Dundee, NY 14837	$94,000	—/—	624	0.04

Estimated values are based on public record data and automated valuation models. Values are not guaranteed and may not reflect current market conditions.