1. This Place Is Great In Every Way
Gatsby’s On The Bay
695 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10304
(718) 442-8729
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 66 Reviews.
Gatsby’s on the Bay has perfected the art of serving up great American classics with a new twist. With favorites like the seafood risotto and the truffle mac & cheese, their creative menu is hard to beat. If you come here once, it’s a sure thing you’ll be back for more.
2. A Blast From The Bayou On Staten Island
Bayou
1072 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10305
(718) 273-4383
Yelp: 4 Stars; 186 Reviews.
This Creole restaurant sure is a long way from Louisiana, but your taste buds won’t be able to tell the difference. With Cajun classics like N’awlins Chicken and a seafood jambalaya, this restaurant will add the perfect amount of spice to your life.
3. Daddy Knows Best
DaddyO’s BBQ and Sports Bar
35 Androvette St
Staten Island, NY 10309
(718) 948-3333
Yelp: 4 Stars; 130 Reviews.
When the big game is on and your stomach is growling, DaddyO’s is the perfect place to be. Utilizing a menu full of barbecue classics, as well as unique items like macaroni and cheese balls and sweet potato tater tots, DaddyO’s never disappoints. NEVER.
4. Italian Comfort Food At Its Finest
Alor Pasta
2508 Hylan Blvd
Staten Island, NY 10306
(718) 668-2600
Yelp: 4.5 Stars 28 Reviews.
If you’re in the mood for a hearty meal, head to Alor Pasta. With tons of awesome Italian dishes, this place will have your stomach smiling in no time. Just make sure you don’t leave without trying the chocolate ravioli, a truly unique and delicious dessert item.
5. As Close To The Mediterranean As You Can Get In Staten Island
Zaghloul Grill
61 New Dorp Plaza N
Staten Island, NY 10306
(718) 987-4444
Yelp: 4 Stars; 20 Reviews.
With a menu inspired by Mediterranean classics, Zaghloul offers up something for everyone. With plenty of vegetarian options, as well as meaty favorites, Zaghloul is a staple of Staten Island cuisine.
Need a recommendation? Try the chicken shawarma or the jumbo shrimp kabobs.
6. Not Your Typical Diner
The Gavel Grill
9 Hyatt St
Staten Island, NY 10301
(718) 876-9596
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 23 Reviews.
Sure, there are tons of “diners” on Staten Island, but the Gavel Grill is a step above the rest. Always with reasonable prices, this place serves up tons of awesome meals throughout the day.
If you want the best, head there for breakfast, where you can get an awesome fully stuffed omelet for around $6.
7. You’ll Never Feel So Close To Peru
Inca’s Grill Peruvian Cuisine
2110 Clove Rd
Staten Island, NY 10305
(718) 448-0488
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 21 Reviews.
If you’re looking to experience authentic Peruvian cuisine, you’ve found the perfect place. With dishes that can be traced back to the legendary Incan Empire, this restaurant develops flavors you can’t find anywhere else on Staten Island. With awesome options like the Caviche Limeño and the chicken dish “pollos ala brasa”, you’ll love everything you try. Just make sure you save room for a slice of their awesome Lucuma cheese cake.
8. Holy Schnitzel, This Place Is Delicious
Holy Schnitzel
438 Nome Ave
State Island, NY 10314
(718) 761-4659
Yelp: 4 Stars; 21 Reviews.
This Middle Eastern restaurant will become an instant favorite. With tons of kosher food options, quick service, and a menu containing everything from spicy buffalo steak to delicious falafels, Holy Schnitzel is a must-try on Staten Island.
9. You Had Me At Tater Tot Tower
Lunchbox
1612 Forest Ave
Staten Island, NY 10302
(718) 448-2929
Yelp: 4 Stars; 56 Reviews.
Lunchbox has no problem adding a bit of flair to time tested American classics. While this kitchen serves up plenty of items like the sloppy joe, the chicken sandwich, and ice cream shakes, the “tater tot tower” is where the menu gets really creative. It’s literally a tower of tater tots held together by all things delicious with plenty of cheese and bacon.
10. This Japanese Joint Is Just Right
Hokkaido
3295 Amboy Rd
Staten Island, NY 10306
(718) 980-0880
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 60 Reviews.
Hokkaido isn’t your typical sushi joint. While they serve up all of the standard sushi rolls, their specialty dishes are the most impressive options.
One local favorites is the kimchee salmon, a truly inspired dish that will leave you craving more.
11. Mama Mia, This Place Is Delicious
Pizzeria Giove
278 New Dorp Ln
Staten Island, NY 10306
(347) 286-0635
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 112 Reviews.
If you’re hunting for a delicious slice of pizza on Staten Island, the search is over. Pizzeria Giove is the only place you’ll ever need. Using only the freshest ingredients around, their creative variation of toppings make their pies stand out in a very saturated market.
The award-winning Variopinta is the specialty pie here that everyone orders. Driven by the delicious combination of pancetta and zucchini, you can’t blame them.
12. This Deli Never Fails To Deliver
Marie’s Gourmet
977 Victory Blvd
Staten Island, NY 10301
(718) 981-4664
Yelp: 4 Stars; 63 Reviews.
Whether you’re ordering the breakfast pizza, the bacon cheeseburger, or the French onion soup, you can’t go wrong. Everything on Marie’s menu is absolutely amazing. Just one try will have you recommending this place to all your friends.
13. Welcome To A Foodie’s Paradise
Paradise Restaurant
1281 Arthur Kill Rd
Staten Island, NY 10312
(718) 967-9333
Yelp: 4.5 Stars; 12 Reviews.
With every dish equal parts beautiful and delicious, Paradise Restaurant is one of Staten Island’s finest eateries. Blowing away the competition, savory options like the crab stuffed, bacon wrapped shrimp and the sweet fried ice cream crepes can’t be beat.
14. The Best Mexican On Staten Island
Fiesta Poblano
31 Corson Ave
Staten Island, NY 10301
(347) 855-2668
Yelp: 4 Stars; 61 Reviews.
Whether it’s your first time through the doors or if you’re a seasoned veteran, the food at Fiesta Poblano will never let you down. While it’s hard to narrow their expansive menu down to just one choice, the house specialty, jumbo shrimp topped with a tequila and mango sauce is one for the record books.
15. Add A Little Phunk To Your Life
The Phunky Elephant
1271 Bay St
Staten Island, NY 10305
(718)448-4282
Yelp: 3.5 Stars; 89 Reviews.
The Phunky Elephant is one of the best places on Staten Island to start a big night out with a few drinks and a bite to eat.
With tons of hearty comfort food like the mac & cheese spring rolls and braised short ribs, this gastropub brings a new exciting option to the Staten Island nightlife scene. Like an elephant, you won’t be able to forget the amazing meal you have here.
