309 Mill Stream Way
Williamsburg, VA 23185

4 Bd   3.1 Ba   3,891 Sqft   518 Days
A generous, open floor plan, private lot with water view, and tastefully updated kitchen are the centerpiece of this custom built, original owner home in popular Settler’s Mill. Great for entertaining, with formal and informal spaces separated by a wide central staircase. Recently refinished hardwood floors grace the main level, including the master suite. Beautiful new kitchen is open to the two story family room and boasts new granite and all new high-end appliances. The large deck with access from the family room and master bedroom overlooks a private back yard with view of a small pond. Upstairs are two generously sized bedrooms, bath, and large loft which could easily be converted to a 5th bedroom. On the lower level a large finished room with fireplace has plenty of space for sitting and games as well as bedroom, full bath, and separate laundry. With direct access from the driveway, this could easily serve as an in-law suite. Want more space? Check out the more than 1000 sqft of unfinished space ready for you to put your stamp on it.
  • HOA $63/mo
  • $120/Sqft
  • MLS#1612992 provided by Tony Pauroso of Liz Moore & Associates-2
  • Movoto last checked CVRMLS for new data 12 minutes ago
  • CVRMLS last updated this listing 9 months ago

Home Features for 309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg

Year Built: 2004
Acres: 0.38
Total SQFT: 3891
Lot Description: Landscaped, Sloping, Waterview, Wooded
Lot: 5
Annual Taxes: 4040
Parcel Number: 47-1-19-0-0005
Tax Year: 2016
Fee Period: Quarterly
Fee Includes: Comm Ar Mnt, Common Area, Management Fees, Pool, Recreational Facilities
Fee Description: Owners Association
Additional Fee: 500
Fee: 190
Association Y/N: 1
Full Bathrooms Level 2 Description: Tub & Shower
Full Bathrooms Level 1 Description: Tub & Shower
Full Bathrooms Basement: 1
Full Bathrooms Level 2: 1
Full Bathrooms Level 1: 1
Full Bathrooms Basement Description: Shower
Full Bathrooms: 3
1/2 Bathrooms: 1
Total Bathrooms: 3.1
1/2 Bathrooms Level 1: 1
Total Bedrooms: 4
Basement Y/N: 1
Basement Type: Basement-Full, Finished-Part, Walk-Out
Basement Unfinished SQFT: 1086
Basement Finished SQFT: 726
Flooring: Carpet-W-W, Tile-Ceramic, Wood
Attic: Pull Down
Interior: 1st Floor Master Bedroom, 9 Ft + Ceilings, Butlers Pantry, Cathedral Ceiling, Ceiling Fan, Countertops - Granite/Stone, Dining Area, Double Vanity, Jetted Tub, Pantry, Walk-In Closet
Style: Colonial
Roof: Asphalt
Structure: Frame
Zoning: R1
Siding: Brick
Exterior: Deck, Irrigation System, Outdoor Lighting, Thermal Windows
Garage Type: Attached, Auto Door Opener
Cars: 2
Garage Y/N: 1
Parking: Paved Driveway
Porch: Deck, Stoop
Amenities / Utilities
Cooling: 2 Zoned AC, Central Air
Fireplace: Gas
Heating: 2 Zoned Heat
Heat Fuel: Electric
Water Type: Pond
Sewer: Public Sewer
Water: Public Water
Appliances / Equipment: Dishwasher, Dryer, Freezer, Gas Cooking, Ice Maker, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stove, Washer
Disability Equipped Y/N: 1
Disability Equipment: Grab Bars, Wide Doorways Or Min. 32" Wide Doors
Amenity: Association, Basketball, Lifeguard, Picnic Area, Playground, Pool, Professional Management, Tennis Court
Waterfront: Yes
Area: 118 - James City Co.
Elementary School: Clara Byrd Baker
Middle School: Berkeley
High School: Jamestown
Directions: Rt 199 To Jamestown Rd; R On Lakewood Dr; R On Mill Stream Way
See More
Talk to Movoto
About Selling

Compare Similar Homes for 309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg

Price estimate is $529,176 based on the following nearby homes for sale which average $136/Sqft
Movoto's Price/Sqft estimate is not a professional appraisal, it is a starting point to help you price this home. Contact a Movoto Real Estate agent today to get a comprehensive evaluation
You can refine the estimate by removing homes that are not similar
A 0.20 mi
124 Mill Stream Way
  • $450,000
  • For Sale

    26 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 2.1 Ba
  • 3,100 Sqft
  • $145 /Sqft
  • 0.53 Acres Lot
  • Built 1998
B 0.46 mi
102 N Sulgrave Ct
  • $358,000
  • Price Reduced

    56 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 2.1 Ba
  • 3,112 Sqft
  • $115 /Sqft
  • 0.59 Acres Lot
  • Built 1972
C 0.96 mi
2808 Strategy Ct
  • $375,000
  • For Sale

    12 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 3,032 Sqft
  • $124 /Sqft
  • 7,388 Sqft Lot
  • Built 2001
D 1.09 mi
3805 Abington Park
  • $379,900
  • New

    6 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 2,357 Sqft
  • $161 /Sqft
  • 6,229 Sqft Lot
  • Built 2005
309 Mill Stream Way
  • $468,000
  • Sold

    518 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 3.1 Ba
  • 3,891 Sqft
  • $120 /Sqft
  • 0.38 Acres Lot
  • Built 2004

Property History for 309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg

Dec 15, 2016
Oct 29, 2016
Price Change
Aug 23, 2016
Price Change
Jun 15, 2016
Apr 20, 2016

Real Estate Market Statistics for 309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg


309 Mill Stream Way

No data!
James City County
List Price
Homes for Sale
Days on Movoto

List Price


309 Mill Stream Way



0% y/y




-2% y/y



James City County

- y/y

James City County

See all trends for Williamsburg

Public Record for 309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg

4 Beds
2 Baths
3,273 Sqft Building Area
Single Family Residential
1 Partial Baths
9 Rooms
16,553 Sqft Lot Size
2004 Year Built
$403,370 Last Sale Price
09/02/2004 Last Sale Date
Full Basement Basement
Siding (Alum/Vinyl) Exterior Walls
Composition Shingle Roof Cover
Attached Garage Garage Type
2 Garage # of Cars
Forced air unit Heating
Yes Cooling
Y Fire Place
309 Mill Stream Way in 23185 was last listed for $468,000. As of today, , this is 30% above the current median price of $359,900 for the city of Williamsburg, VA and 38% above the median of $339,500 for ZIP code 23185. Right now, there are 405 properties for sale in 23185 and 768 properties listed for sale in Williamsburg. Those 768 properties are made up of 554 single family homes and 214 condos. The square footage of 309 Mill Stream Way is approximately 3,891, which is 56% above the median size of 2,500 Sqft in Williamsburg and 63% above the median size of 2,380 Sqft in ZIP code 23185. This property's price per square foot was $120, which is 19% below the current $148 median in 23185 and 19% below the $148 Williamsburg median.
Built in 2004, this 4-bedroom, 3.1-bathroom single family house at 309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg VA, 23185 is approximately 3,891 square feet and comes with 2 parking spots. It was last listed with a cost per Sqft of $120. Homeowners association fees total $63 per month. 309 Mill Stream Way is located in the Williamsburg-James City Public Schools. The closest school is Clara Byrd Baker Elementary School.

309 Mill Stream Way, Williamsburg VA, 23185 was on the market for 518 days. The median days on the market for properties in this area is 70 with a median list price of $359,900 and median cost per square foot of $148. Its current status is sold under the MLS #1612992.

View active properties and off-market properties in this area. Or connect with a top-rated Movoto agent to learn about Williamsburg market trends and find homes like this one.
Williamsburg Agent

I'm happy to give you a quick call to answer all your questions about this home and schedule a tour.