58 Lake Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964

4 Bd   3 Ba   2,090 Sqft
Stone's Throw From Lake, Down The Street From Public Beach. Secret Garden Hideaway On A Level Hill Top Acre+ With Mature Gardens, Gazebo, Wrap Around Dining Deck, Fenced, Private, Heated, Slate Surround Gunite Pool + Lawn To Play On. The 2 Owner's Suites, Sole Upstairs + Main Floor Also Boats 2 Additional Guest Rooms, Finished Den On Lower Level With Walk Out 2 Car Garage
  • Zipcode: 11964
  • Days on Movoto: 750
  • Year Built: 1978
  • HOA: $0 HOA
  • $/Sqft: $476
  • Lot: 1.10 Acres
  • Property Type: Single Family
  • MLS#: 2770167
  • MLS:
  • Listing Office: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
  • Listed By: Cincotta, Susan C

Home Features for 58 Lake Drive, Shelter Island

Overview
Go Tour Nearby Homes

Property History for 58 Lake Drive, Shelter Island

Status
Date
Price
Price Change
Oct 3, 2016
$970,000
Price Change
Sep 5, 2016
$995,000
Price Change
May 30, 2016
$1,075,000
Price Change
Nov 2, 2015
$1,100,000
Listed
Jun 4, 2015
$1,200,000
#2770167

Public Record for 58 Lake Drive, Shelter Island

4 Beds
3 Baths
2,090 Sqft Building Area
Single Family Residential
1.1 AC Lot Size
1978 Year Built
$570,000 Last Sale Price
12/07/2000 Last Sale Date
Full Basement Basement
Contemporary Style
Wood Exterior Walls
Hot Water Heating
Central Cooling
Pool (yes) Pool
1 Fire Place

Compare Similar Homes for 58 Lake Drive, Shelter Island

Price estimate is $1,373,130 based on the following nearby homes which average $657/Sqft
You can refine the estimate by removing homes that are not similar
A 2.88 mi
6 Country Club Dr
  • $1,175,000
  • For Sale

    51 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 4 Ba
  • 2,958 Sqft
  • $397 /Sqft
  • 40,946 Sqft Lot
  • Built 1994
B 3.17 mi
2295 Bay Shore Rd
  • $1,159,000
  • For Sale

    42 days

  • 3 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 1,050 Sqft
  • $1,104 /Sqft
  • 42,253 Sqft Lot
  • Built 1953
C 3.52 mi
9502 N Bayview Rd
  • $750,000
  • For Sale

    39 days

  • 3 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 2.44 Acres Lot
  • Built —
D 3.75 mi
275 Maple St
  • $799,000
  • For Sale

    26 days

  • 3 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 1,700 Sqft
  • $470 /Sqft
  • 7,405 Sqft Lot
  • Built 1950
YOU
ARE
HERE
58 Lake Dr
  • $995,000
  • DELISTED

    750 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 2,090 Sqft
  • $476 /Sqft
  • 1.10 Acres Lot
  • Built 1978
Built in 1978, this 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom single family house at 58 Lake Dr, Shelter Island NY, 11964 is approximately 2,090 square feet and comes with 2 parking spots. It was last listed with a cost per Sqft of $476. The closest school is Shelter Island School.

58 Lake Dr, Shelter Island NY, 11964 was on the market for 750 days. The median days on the market for properties in this area is 109 with a median list price of $1,350,000 and median cost per square foot of $455. Its current status is removed under the MLS #2770167.

View active properties and off-market properties in this area. Or connect with a top-rated Movoto agent to learn about Shelter Island market trends and find homes like this one.

Meet with a real estate agent today Call (877) 505-9582.

Movoto
Shelter Island Agent

I'm happy to give you a quick call to answer all your questions about this home and schedule a tour.