00 Old Garden Creek Rd
Mathews, VA 23109

3 Bd   Ba   1,380 Sqft   353 Days
20 acres of forest, cleared areas, tidal marsh and marshland, perfect for nature lovers or as a hunting or fishing lodge. Long water frontage along Garden Creek. Large area of marsh grasses from the property out to the creek center. This would be the perfect place to build an observation deck for birdwatching. Garden Creek goes out to Winter Harbor and the Chesapeake Bay. This home was built in the late 1800s. The current owner purchased it for use as a getaway from the modern world. The home has never been wired for electricity and has no plumbing or running water. The rooms are heated by wood burning fireplace and wood stoves. There is a well on site that uses a hand pump to dispense water. There is a septic system installed in the front yard that is not connected. Home is being sold AS-IS. New roof with architectural shingles was installed in the last couple of years. Bethel Natural Area is less than 2 miles away, which is an 83-acre Chesapeake Bay front preserve of sandy beach, low dunes and salt marshes. This home and the surrounding area are an absolutely awesome area for walking, kayaking, biking and birdwatching.
  • $0 HOA
  • $54/Sqft
  • MLS#1634138 provided by Andrea Holt of IsaBell K. Horsley Real Estate
  • Movoto last checked CVRMLS for new data 14 minutes ago
  • CVRMLS last updated this listing 6 months ago

Home Features for 00 Old Garden Creek Road, Mathews

Year Built: 1900
Acres: 20
Total SQFT: 1380
Lot Description: Level, Timber-Pine, Waterfront
Lot: 189
Lot Dimensions: 20 Acres
Annual Taxes: 444
Parcel Number: 31-A-189
Tax Year: 2016
Virtual Tour: External Link
Total Bedrooms: 3
Basement Type: Other
Flooring: Wood
Attic: No Attic
Wall Type: Plaster
Style: 2-Story, Farm House
Roof: Composition, Dimensional
Structure: Frame, Wood
Siding: Wood
Farm Type: Horse, Tree
Exterior: Horse Permitted
Garage Type: No Garage
Parking: Off Street
Porch: Stoop
Amenities / Utilities
Cooling: None
Fireplace: Wood Burning
Heating: Wood Stove
Heat Fuel: Wood
Water Type: Access, Creek Frontage, MLW 2-4 Ft, Walk To Water, Water Access
Sewer: Conventional Septic, Other
Water Depth: 2-4 Ft
Water: Well
Water Frontage: 625
Waterfront: Yes
Neighborhood Name: Near Bethel Beach
Area: 114 - Mathews
Body Of Water: Garden Creek
Elementary School: Mathews
Middle School: Mathews
High School: Mathews
Directions: From The Hardees In Mathews Take Main St South To A Left On Tabernacle. Right On Garden Creek. Left On Old Garden Creek. Home Is On The Left And Is Next Door To 1057 Old Garden Creek.
See More
Talk to Movoto
About Selling

Compare Similar Homes for 00 Old Garden Creek Road, Mathews

Price estimate is $114,540 based on the following nearby homes for sale which average $83/Sqft
Movoto's Price/Sqft estimate is not a professional appraisal, it is a starting point to help you price this home. Contact a Movoto Real Estate agent today to get a comprehensive evaluation
You can refine the estimate by removing homes that are not similar
A 7.78 mi
158 N End Rd
  • $90,000
  • Price Reduced

    24 days

  • 2 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 848 Sqft
  • $106 /Sqft
  • Built 1910
B 12.75 mi
1583 Windmill Point Rd
  • $74,900
  • For Sale

    18 days

  • 2 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 1,456 Sqft
  • $51 /Sqft
  • 1.14 Acres Lot
  • Built 1987
C 21.70 mi
135 Buzzards Neck Rd
  • $89,000
  • Price Reduced

    73 days

  • 2 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 1,084 Sqft
  • $82 /Sqft
  • 0.75 Acres Lot
  • Built 1960
D 24.42 mi
784 Windbrook Cir # 304
  • $87,900
  • For Sale

    20 days

  • 1 Bd
  • 1 Ba
  • 957 Sqft
  • $92 /Sqft
  • Built 1990
00 Old Garden Creek Rd
  • $75,000
  • Sold

    353 days

  • 3 Bd
  • — Ba
  • 1,380 Sqft
  • $54 /Sqft
  • 20.00 Acres Lot
  • Built 1900

Property History for 00 Old Garden Creek Road, Mathews

Mar 1, 2017
Jan 13, 2017
Oct 7, 2016

Real Estate Market Statistics for 00 Old Garden Creek Road, Mathews


00 Old Garden Creek Road

No data!
Mathews County
List Price
Homes for Sale
Days on Movoto

List Price


00 Old Garden Creek Road



6% y/y




4% y/y



Mathews County

- y/y

Mathews County

See all trends for Mathews
As of , there are 60 properties listed for sale in ZIP code 23109 and 61 properties listed for sale in the city of Mathews, VA. Those 61 properties include 61 single family homes and 0 condos. This property at 00 Old Garden Creek Rd in 23109 was last listed for $75,000. This is 79% below the current median price of $350,000 for Mathews and 79% below the median of $359,500 for 23109. 00 Old Garden Creek Rd is approximately 1,380 Sqft, which is 40% below the Mathews median of 2,306 and 40% below the 23109 ZIP code median of 2,319. This property's price per Sqft was $54, which is 69% below the current median price in 23109 of $177 and 70% below the Mathews median of $182 per Sqft.
Built in 1900, this 3-bedroom single family house at 00 Old Garden Creek Rd, Mathews VA, 23109 is approximately 1,380 square feet and does not come with a parking spot. It was last listed with a cost per Sqft of $54.

00 Old Garden Creek Rd, Mathews VA, 23109 was on the market for 353 days. The median days on the market for properties in this area is 116 with a median list price of $350,000 and median cost per square foot of $182. Its current status is sold under the MLS #1634138.

View active properties and off-market properties in this area. Or connect with a top-rated Movoto agent to learn about Mathews market trends and find homes like this one.
Mathews Agent

I'm happy to give you a quick call to answer all your questions about this home and schedule a tour.