5189 Plaster Point Rd
Cayuga, NY 13034

3 Bd   1.1 Ba   1,452 Sqft
This year round ranch is located at the end of a well maintained private road in a prime lakeside community.Kitchen and baths are updated with newer appliances, an open floor plan allows for entertaining. Sliding glass doors on the lakeside lead to new deck , a perfect place to enjoy wonderful sunsets. The newer addition has a family room with another fireplace which leads onto a covered deck, wonderful for outside entertaining. All public Utilities and high speed internet. A large 12 X 24 shed/workshop and a smaller shed, perfect for the watertoys. Dock is included. This home has a nice level shoreline, a perfect spot to have campfires under the stars. Start making memories. Close to Syracuse, Rochester or Ithaca, A perfect Finger Lakes lakehouse.
  • Zipcode: 13034
  • Days on Movoto: 15
  • Year Built: 1960
  • HOA: $13/month
  • $/Sqft: $206
  • Lot:
  • Property Type: Single Family
  • MLS#: S1007328
  • MLS:
  • Listing Office: LAKE COUNTRY REAL ESTATE, Inc.
  • Listing Broker: MIDGE FRICANO
  • Movoto last checked Western New York for new data Just now
  • Western New York last updated this listing 6 days ago

Home Features for 5189 Plaster Point Rd , Cayuga

Schedule a Viewing of 5189 Plaster Point Rd, Cayuga

Mortgage Calculator for 5189 Plaster Point Road, Cayuga

Edit the averages shown below to see the payment that works best for you.

Real Estate Market Statistics of 5189 Plaster Point Road , Cayuga

Cayuga, New York

Total Inventory For Sale

13 Homes

0% m/m -27% y/y

Median List Price


0% m/m +41% y/y

Median Days On Market

93 Days

+2% m/m -29% y/y

Median House Size

1,600 Sqft

0% m/m 0% y/y

Median Price Per Square Foot

$137 /Sqft

0% m/m +24% y/y

Median Price

As of , there are 13 properties listed for sale in ZIP code 13034 and 13 properties listed for sale in the city of Cayuga, NY. Those 13 properties include 13 single family homes and 0 condos. This property at 5189 Plaster Point Rd in 13034 is currently listed for $299,000. This is 36% above the median price of $219,900 for Cayuga and 36% above the median of $219,900 for 13034. 5189 Plaster Point Rd is approximately 1,452 Sqft, which is 9% below the Cayuga median of 1,600 and 9% below the 13034 ZIP code median of 1,600. This property's price per square foot is $206, which is 50% above the median price in 13034 of $137 and 50% above the Cayuga median of $137 per square foot.

Nearby Homes For Saleof 5189 Plaster Point Road, Cayuga

For Sale
3 2 2,030
6989 Owasco Rd, Auburn
For Sale
3 1.1 1,456
5418 Route 89, Romulus
For Sale
4 2.1 1,960
6 Dublin Hl, Aurora
For Sale
3 1.1 2,058
5262 State Route 89, Romulus
For Sale
3 2.1 1,188
6577 State Route 90 N, Cayuga
For Sale

Awesome Similar Homes Real Estate listings near 5189 Plaster Point Rd , Cayuga NY 13034

For Sale
For Sale Open
2 2 1,225
5768 Sunset Ct, Romulus
For Sale
3 1.1 1,528
10 Fuller St, Skaneateles
For Sale
3 2 1,568
3 Cambridge Cir, Auburn
For Sale
2 1.1 1,704
5471 E Lake Rd, Romulus
For Sale
3 2.1 1,884
3154 Meadowview Ln, Auburn
Built in 1960, this 3-bedroom, 1.1-bathroom single family house at 5189 Plaster Point Rd is approximately 1,452 square feet and does not come with a parking spot. It is listed on 10/09/2016 for $299,000 with a cost per Sqft of $206. Homeowners association fees total $13 per month. The closest school is Union Springs Middle School High School.

5189 Plaster Point Rd has been on the market for 15 days. The median days on the market for properties in this area is 93 with a median list price of $219,900 and median cost per square foot of $137. It's currently listed as active under the MLS #S1007328.

View more active properties in this area. Or connect with a top-rated Movoto agent to learn more about Cayuga market trends and buying this home and other homes like it.
Cayuga Agent

I'm happy to give you a quick call to answer all your questions about this home and schedule a tour.