915 Columbia Ave
Cape May, NJ 08204

5 Bd   3.1 Ba   2,600 Sqft   179 Days
A home that you have dreamed about with plenty of room for EVERYONE! Don't be fooled by what looks like a small property from the front yard, this enchanted private oasis is magical and you need to see it from the private drive located off of Page Street to believe it. This lovely seashore home built in 2000 sits on a 38x266 foot lot (yes....266 ft. situated in the heart of town!). The first floor of the home offers a master bedroom and en-suite bath with lovely walk-in closet making it an ideal retirement spot. A front room office is also featured on the first floor with French doors to allow for those days you want to work from home or from your shore house. This office space can easily be a 6th bedroom and offers a sleeper sofa for the extra guests. The state of the art kitchen features granite counters and ample work space to make those large family meals. Off of the kitchen is a wide open expanded great room/living space featuring a fireplace for those cozy contemplative winter nights. The great room offers a nice sized dining area and breakfast bar too. Just beyond the great room is the amazing HUGE Florida room which spans the full width of the house with ample space for everyone to gather together for large family summer meals and is a super location for the kids to play games after a long day on the beach. The second floor maintains a lovely private deck off of the 2nd floor front den (or 7th bedroom). Enjoy the sun-filled morning with your cup of coffee from here. The 4 other spacious bedrooms and two baths make this home a MUST see and a MUST have. The MOST unbelievable feature that is unheard of in the heart of town is the magical back yard that boasts an enchanted entrance from the quiet, tucked away Page Street. Off of this secluded drive you will enter into the best kept secret in town - the private, over-sized back yard where you drive right into your detached over-sized 2 car garag, tons of parking for everyone! A massive play area with playset for the kids makes this retreat hard to believe. Walk from the garage area into the sweet additional fenced yard off of the rear of the house where you will find the private backyard outdoor shower. This rear yard area is shocking you must see it to believe it. Truly the best kept secret in all of Cape May. This Columbia Ave home is being sold completely TURN-KEY all the furnishings, pots, pans dishes you name it! Simply bring your flip flops this one has it all! Call today for your appointment don't wait. Rental history can be provided, owner allowed 4-5 prime weeks a year to share her home with rental guests the rest of the year it was the owners primary residence lovingly decorated and cared for.
  • $0 HOA
  • $331/Sqft
  • MLS#172101 provided by Dagmer Chew of HOMESTEAD REAL ESTATE C0. INC.
  • Movoto last checked Cape May County MLS for new data 8 hours ago
  • Cape May County MLS last updated this listing 6 months ago

Home Features for 915 Columbia Avenue, Cape May

Approx Year Built: 2000
Lot Size: 10000-20000 SqFt, 38x266 Irr
Lot Number: 1090
Block Number: 43
Taxes: 7582
Bank Owned: No
Sale/Rent: For Sale
Full Baths: 3
Total Baths: 3.1
Bedrooms: 5
Total Rooms: 10
Appx Living Square Feet: 2600
New Construction Y/N: No
House Color: Tan
Amenities / Utilities
HOT WATER: Electric
Area: Cape May
LOCATION: Inside Lot
Frontage: 38
District - Township: 02-Cape May City
Near: Center Of Town Beaches
See More
Talk to Movoto
About Selling

Compare Similar Homes for 915 Columbia Avenue, Cape May

Price estimate is $832,000 based on the following nearby homes for sale which average $320/Sqft
Movoto's Price/Sqft estimate is not a professional appraisal, it is a starting point to help you price this home. Contact a Movoto Real Estate agent today to get a comprehensive evaluation
You can refine the estimate by removing homes that are not similar
A 0.12 mi
925 Corgie St
  • $1,075,000
  • Price Reduced

    10 days

  • 5 Bd
  • 3 Ba
  • 0.26 Acres Lot
  • Built 1850
B 0.22 mi
904 Benton Ave
  • $780,000
  • For Sale

    8 days

  • 3 Bd
  • 1.1 Ba
  • 6,300 Sqft Lot
  • Built 1955
C 0.52 mi
202 Reading Ave
  • $849,900
  • For Sale

    22 days

  • 3 Bd
  • 2 Ba
  • 3,780 Sqft Lot
  • Built —
D 0.63 mi
724 Park Blvd
  • $719,000
  • For Sale

    56 days

  • 4 Bd
  • 4.1 Ba
  • 2,250 Sqft
  • $320 /Sqft
  • 7,622 Sqft Lot
  • Built 2016
915 Columbia Ave
  • $860,000
  • Sold

    179 days

  • 5 Bd
  • 3.1 Ba
  • 2,600 Sqft
  • $331 /Sqft
  • 10,108 Sqft Lot
  • Built 2000

Property History for 915 Columbia Avenue, Cape May

Sold In-House
Feb 25, 2017
Under Contract
Dec 9, 2016
Price Change
Oct 14, 2016
Aug 29, 2016

Real Estate Market Statistics for 915 Columbia Avenue, Cape May


915 Columbia Avenue

No data!
Cape May County
Cape May
List Price
Homes for Sale
Days on Movoto

List Price


915 Columbia Avenue



9% y/y



Cape May

9% y/y

Cape May


Cape May County

66% y/y

Cape May County

See all trends for Cape May

Public Record for 915 Columbia Avenue, Cape May

2,629 Sqft Building Area
Single Family Residential
2000 Year Built
$100,000 Last Sale Price
09/14/2010 Last Sale Date
Frame Construction Type
Detached Garage Garage Type
2 Garage # of Cars
915 Columbia Ave in 08204 was last listed for $860,000. As of today, , this is 79% above the current median price of $479,900 for the city of Cape May, NJ and 79% above the median of $480,000 for ZIP code 08204. Right now, there are 149 properties for sale in 08204 and 151 properties listed for sale in Cape May. Those 151 properties are made up of 101 single family homes and 50 condos. The square footage of 915 Columbia Ave is approximately 2,600, which is 28% above the median size of 2,033 Sqft in Cape May and 42% above the median size of 1,832 square feet in ZIP code 08204. This property's price per square foot was $331, which is 6% above the current $311 median in 08204 and 1% above the $327 Cape May median.

Awesome Similar Homes in Cape May

Built in 2000, this 5-bedroom, 3.1-bathroom single family house at 915 Columbia Ave, Cape May NJ, 08204 is approximately 2,600 square feet and comes with 4 parking spots. It was last listed with a cost per Sqft of $331. 915 Columbia Ave is located in the Cape May City Board Of Education School District. The closest school is Cape May City Elementary School.

915 Columbia Ave, Cape May NJ, 08204 was on the market for 179 days. The median days on the market for properties in this area is 118 with a median list price of $479,900 and median cost per square foot of $327. Its current status is sold under the MLS #172101.

View active properties and off-market properties in this area. Or connect with a top-rated Movoto agent to learn about Cape May market trends and find homes like this one.
Cape May Agent

I'm happy to give you a quick call to answer all your questions about this home and schedule a tour.